PTIJ: If Haman would have fallen with no one around to hear him fall, would that still have made a sound?












4















Esther 7:8 writes:




והמלך שב מגנת הביתן אל־בית משתה היין והמן נפל על־המטה אשר אסתר עליה ויאמר המלך הגם לכבוש את־המלכה עמי בבית הדבר יצא מפי המלך ופני המן חפו



When the king returned from the palace garden to the banquet room, Haman fell on the couch on which Esther reclined. “Does he mean,” cried the king, “to ravish the queen in my own palace?” No sooner did these words leave the king’s lips than Haman’s face was covered.




The Megillah makes it clear that Achashverosh was in the room when Haman fell, but I can't help but wonder:



If Haman would have fallen with no one around to hear him fall, would that still have made a sound?





This question is Purim Torah and is not intended to be taken completely seriously. See the Purim Torah policy.










share|improve this question





























    4















    Esther 7:8 writes:




    והמלך שב מגנת הביתן אל־בית משתה היין והמן נפל על־המטה אשר אסתר עליה ויאמר המלך הגם לכבוש את־המלכה עמי בבית הדבר יצא מפי המלך ופני המן חפו



    When the king returned from the palace garden to the banquet room, Haman fell on the couch on which Esther reclined. “Does he mean,” cried the king, “to ravish the queen in my own palace?” No sooner did these words leave the king’s lips than Haman’s face was covered.




    The Megillah makes it clear that Achashverosh was in the room when Haman fell, but I can't help but wonder:



    If Haman would have fallen with no one around to hear him fall, would that still have made a sound?





    This question is Purim Torah and is not intended to be taken completely seriously. See the Purim Torah policy.










    share|improve this question



























      4












      4








      4








      Esther 7:8 writes:




      והמלך שב מגנת הביתן אל־בית משתה היין והמן נפל על־המטה אשר אסתר עליה ויאמר המלך הגם לכבוש את־המלכה עמי בבית הדבר יצא מפי המלך ופני המן חפו



      When the king returned from the palace garden to the banquet room, Haman fell on the couch on which Esther reclined. “Does he mean,” cried the king, “to ravish the queen in my own palace?” No sooner did these words leave the king’s lips than Haman’s face was covered.




      The Megillah makes it clear that Achashverosh was in the room when Haman fell, but I can't help but wonder:



      If Haman would have fallen with no one around to hear him fall, would that still have made a sound?





      This question is Purim Torah and is not intended to be taken completely seriously. See the Purim Torah policy.










      share|improve this question
















      Esther 7:8 writes:




      והמלך שב מגנת הביתן אל־בית משתה היין והמן נפל על־המטה אשר אסתר עליה ויאמר המלך הגם לכבוש את־המלכה עמי בבית הדבר יצא מפי המלך ופני המן חפו



      When the king returned from the palace garden to the banquet room, Haman fell on the couch on which Esther reclined. “Does he mean,” cried the king, “to ravish the queen in my own palace?” No sooner did these words leave the king’s lips than Haman’s face was covered.




      The Megillah makes it clear that Achashverosh was in the room when Haman fell, but I can't help but wonder:



      If Haman would have fallen with no one around to hear him fall, would that still have made a sound?





      This question is Purim Torah and is not intended to be taken completely seriously. See the Purim Torah policy.







      purim-torah-in-jest






      share|improve this question















      share|improve this question













      share|improve this question




      share|improve this question








      edited 2 days ago







      Eliyahu

















      asked 2 days ago









      EliyahuEliyahu

      1,853419




      1,853419






















          2 Answers
          2






          active

          oldest

          votes


















          12














          This is actually an age old debate, as we learn in Bereishis 3:11




          המן העץ



          Haman is a tree




          And therefore, the question you are really asking is, if a tree falls and there is no one around to hear it, does it make a sound? That question is far beyond the scope of this forum to address fully.






          share|improve this answer



















          • 2





            Beyond the scope of Mi Yodeya? Heaven forfend.

            – msh210
            2 days ago



















          0














          No one would know the definitive answer to this either way, despite daily inquiries on the matter.



          Numerous people say פרשת המן - the section describing Haman's affair. (one definition of parsha is "affair"). There's nothing in there that describes what happened to Haman after he fell on the bed. I can understand why there is that omission. He was there with Esther, so it was a private affair.






          share|improve this answer































            2 Answers
            2






            active

            oldest

            votes








            2 Answers
            2






            active

            oldest

            votes









            active

            oldest

            votes






            active

            oldest

            votes









            12














            This is actually an age old debate, as we learn in Bereishis 3:11




            המן העץ



            Haman is a tree




            And therefore, the question you are really asking is, if a tree falls and there is no one around to hear it, does it make a sound? That question is far beyond the scope of this forum to address fully.






            share|improve this answer



















            • 2





              Beyond the scope of Mi Yodeya? Heaven forfend.

              – msh210
              2 days ago
















            12














            This is actually an age old debate, as we learn in Bereishis 3:11




            המן העץ



            Haman is a tree




            And therefore, the question you are really asking is, if a tree falls and there is no one around to hear it, does it make a sound? That question is far beyond the scope of this forum to address fully.






            share|improve this answer



















            • 2





              Beyond the scope of Mi Yodeya? Heaven forfend.

              – msh210
              2 days ago














            12












            12








            12







            This is actually an age old debate, as we learn in Bereishis 3:11




            המן העץ



            Haman is a tree




            And therefore, the question you are really asking is, if a tree falls and there is no one around to hear it, does it make a sound? That question is far beyond the scope of this forum to address fully.






            share|improve this answer













            This is actually an age old debate, as we learn in Bereishis 3:11




            המן העץ



            Haman is a tree




            And therefore, the question you are really asking is, if a tree falls and there is no one around to hear it, does it make a sound? That question is far beyond the scope of this forum to address fully.







            share|improve this answer












            share|improve this answer



            share|improve this answer










            answered 2 days ago









            Y     e     zY     e     z

            45.4k372203




            45.4k372203








            • 2





              Beyond the scope of Mi Yodeya? Heaven forfend.

              – msh210
              2 days ago














            • 2





              Beyond the scope of Mi Yodeya? Heaven forfend.

              – msh210
              2 days ago








            2




            2





            Beyond the scope of Mi Yodeya? Heaven forfend.

            – msh210
            2 days ago





            Beyond the scope of Mi Yodeya? Heaven forfend.

            – msh210
            2 days ago











            0














            No one would know the definitive answer to this either way, despite daily inquiries on the matter.



            Numerous people say פרשת המן - the section describing Haman's affair. (one definition of parsha is "affair"). There's nothing in there that describes what happened to Haman after he fell on the bed. I can understand why there is that omission. He was there with Esther, so it was a private affair.






            share|improve this answer




























              0














              No one would know the definitive answer to this either way, despite daily inquiries on the matter.



              Numerous people say פרשת המן - the section describing Haman's affair. (one definition of parsha is "affair"). There's nothing in there that describes what happened to Haman after he fell on the bed. I can understand why there is that omission. He was there with Esther, so it was a private affair.






              share|improve this answer


























                0












                0








                0







                No one would know the definitive answer to this either way, despite daily inquiries on the matter.



                Numerous people say פרשת המן - the section describing Haman's affair. (one definition of parsha is "affair"). There's nothing in there that describes what happened to Haman after he fell on the bed. I can understand why there is that omission. He was there with Esther, so it was a private affair.






                share|improve this answer













                No one would know the definitive answer to this either way, despite daily inquiries on the matter.



                Numerous people say פרשת המן - the section describing Haman's affair. (one definition of parsha is "affair"). There's nothing in there that describes what happened to Haman after he fell on the bed. I can understand why there is that omission. He was there with Esther, so it was a private affair.







                share|improve this answer












                share|improve this answer



                share|improve this answer










                answered 2 days ago









                DanFDanF

                34.8k528127




                34.8k528127















                    Popular posts from this blog

                    Plaza Victoria

                    Puebla de Zaragoza

                    Musa