Transformation of random variables and joint distributions
$begingroup$
Given a variable $y_i$, normally distributed with 0 mean and $σ_y$ standard deviation
$y_i$ ~ NormalDistribution[0,$σ_y$ ]
I want to obtain with Mathematica:
The distribution of:
$x = bar{y} = frac {sum_{i=1}^ny_i}{n}$The joint distribution of $ (x,y_i )$
probability-or-statistics distributions
New contributor
Andrea2810 is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.
$endgroup$
add a comment |
$begingroup$
Given a variable $y_i$, normally distributed with 0 mean and $σ_y$ standard deviation
$y_i$ ~ NormalDistribution[0,$σ_y$ ]
I want to obtain with Mathematica:
The distribution of:
$x = bar{y} = frac {sum_{i=1}^ny_i}{n}$The joint distribution of $ (x,y_i )$
probability-or-statistics distributions
New contributor
Andrea2810 is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.
$endgroup$
5
$begingroup$
What have you tried? For example, have you seen the documentation onTransformedDistributionandProbabilityDistribution?
$endgroup$
– JimB
Mar 24 at 16:58
$begingroup$
@JimB . I tried thisTransformedDistribution[Sum[y, {i, n}]/n, y [Distributed] NormalDistribution[0, [Sigma]y]]. The result isNormalDistribution[0, [Sigma]y]. However, the correct result should beNormalDistribution[0, [Sigma]y / Sqrt[n]]
$endgroup$
– Andrea2810
Mar 24 at 17:42
1
$begingroup$
You need to "index" the variableyor else Mathematica thinks it is a single variable.
$endgroup$
– JimB
Mar 24 at 22:04
add a comment |
$begingroup$
Given a variable $y_i$, normally distributed with 0 mean and $σ_y$ standard deviation
$y_i$ ~ NormalDistribution[0,$σ_y$ ]
I want to obtain with Mathematica:
The distribution of:
$x = bar{y} = frac {sum_{i=1}^ny_i}{n}$The joint distribution of $ (x,y_i )$
probability-or-statistics distributions
New contributor
Andrea2810 is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.
$endgroup$
Given a variable $y_i$, normally distributed with 0 mean and $σ_y$ standard deviation
$y_i$ ~ NormalDistribution[0,$σ_y$ ]
I want to obtain with Mathematica:
The distribution of:
$x = bar{y} = frac {sum_{i=1}^ny_i}{n}$The joint distribution of $ (x,y_i )$
probability-or-statistics distributions
probability-or-statistics distributions
New contributor
Andrea2810 is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.
New contributor
Andrea2810 is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.
edited Mar 25 at 9:26
J. M. is slightly pensive♦
98.7k10311467
98.7k10311467
New contributor
Andrea2810 is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.
asked Mar 24 at 16:53
Andrea2810Andrea2810
334
334
New contributor
Andrea2810 is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.
New contributor
Andrea2810 is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.
Andrea2810 is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.
5
$begingroup$
What have you tried? For example, have you seen the documentation onTransformedDistributionandProbabilityDistribution?
$endgroup$
– JimB
Mar 24 at 16:58
$begingroup$
@JimB . I tried thisTransformedDistribution[Sum[y, {i, n}]/n, y [Distributed] NormalDistribution[0, [Sigma]y]]. The result isNormalDistribution[0, [Sigma]y]. However, the correct result should beNormalDistribution[0, [Sigma]y / Sqrt[n]]
$endgroup$
– Andrea2810
Mar 24 at 17:42
1
$begingroup$
You need to "index" the variableyor else Mathematica thinks it is a single variable.
$endgroup$
– JimB
Mar 24 at 22:04
add a comment |
5
$begingroup$
What have you tried? For example, have you seen the documentation onTransformedDistributionandProbabilityDistribution?
$endgroup$
– JimB
Mar 24 at 16:58
$begingroup$
@JimB . I tried thisTransformedDistribution[Sum[y, {i, n}]/n, y [Distributed] NormalDistribution[0, [Sigma]y]]. The result isNormalDistribution[0, [Sigma]y]. However, the correct result should beNormalDistribution[0, [Sigma]y / Sqrt[n]]
$endgroup$
– Andrea2810
Mar 24 at 17:42
1
$begingroup$
You need to "index" the variableyor else Mathematica thinks it is a single variable.
$endgroup$
– JimB
Mar 24 at 22:04
5
5
$begingroup$
What have you tried? For example, have you seen the documentation on
TransformedDistribution and ProbabilityDistribution?$endgroup$
– JimB
Mar 24 at 16:58
$begingroup$
What have you tried? For example, have you seen the documentation on
TransformedDistribution and ProbabilityDistribution?$endgroup$
– JimB
Mar 24 at 16:58
$begingroup$
@JimB . I tried this
TransformedDistribution[Sum[y, {i, n}]/n, y [Distributed] NormalDistribution[0, [Sigma]y]]. The result is NormalDistribution[0, [Sigma]y]. However, the correct result should be NormalDistribution[0, [Sigma]y / Sqrt[n]]$endgroup$
– Andrea2810
Mar 24 at 17:42
$begingroup$
@JimB . I tried this
TransformedDistribution[Sum[y, {i, n}]/n, y [Distributed] NormalDistribution[0, [Sigma]y]]. The result is NormalDistribution[0, [Sigma]y]. However, the correct result should be NormalDistribution[0, [Sigma]y / Sqrt[n]]$endgroup$
– Andrea2810
Mar 24 at 17:42
1
1
$begingroup$
You need to "index" the variable
y or else Mathematica thinks it is a single variable.$endgroup$
– JimB
Mar 24 at 22:04
$begingroup$
You need to "index" the variable
y or else Mathematica thinks it is a single variable.$endgroup$
– JimB
Mar 24 at 22:04
add a comment |
3 Answers
3
active
oldest
votes
$begingroup$
I don't know how to get Mathematica to get the joint distribution explicitly for a general value of $n$ but here is how one can easily see the pattern to figure out the general solution.
First the distribution of the mean:
marginalDistribution = TransformedDistribution[Sum[y[i], {i, n}]/n,
Table[y[i] [Distributed] NormalDistribution[0, [Sigma]], {i, n}],
Assumptions -> [Sigma] > 0]
{#, marginalDistribution/.n->#} &/@Range[2,10]
$$
begin{array}{cc}
2 & text{NormalDistribution}left[0,frac{sigma }{sqrt{2}}right] \
3 & text{NormalDistribution}left[0,frac{sigma }{sqrt{3}}right] \
4 & text{NormalDistribution}left[0,frac{sigma }{2}right] \
5 & text{NormalDistribution}left[0,frac{sigma }{sqrt{5}}right] \
6 & text{NormalDistribution}left[0,frac{sigma }{sqrt{6}}right] \
7 & text{NormalDistribution}left[0,frac{sigma }{sqrt{7}}right] \
8 & text{NormalDistribution}left[0,frac{sigma }{2 sqrt{2}}right] \
9 & text{NormalDistribution}left[0,frac{sigma }{3}right] \
10 & text{NormalDistribution}left[0,frac{sigma }{sqrt{10}}right] \
end{array}
$$
So we see that the marginal distribution of $bar{y}$ is
NormalDistribution[0, σ/Sqrt[n]]
The joint distribution of $bar{y}$ and, say, $y_1$ is given by
jointDistribution = TransformedDistribution[{y[1], Sum[y[i], {i, n}]/n},
Table[y[i] [Distributed] NormalDistribution[0, [Sigma]], {i, n}]]
{#, jointDistribution /. n -> #} & /@ Range[2, 10] // TableForm
$$
begin{array}{cc}
2 & text{MultinormalDistribution}left[{0,0},left(
begin{array}{cc}
sigma ^2 & frac{sigma ^2}{2} \
frac{sigma ^2}{2} & frac{sigma ^2}{2} \
end{array}
right)right] \
3 & text{MultinormalDistribution}left[{0,0},left(
begin{array}{cc}
sigma ^2 & frac{sigma ^2}{3} \
frac{sigma ^2}{3} & frac{sigma ^2}{3} \
end{array}
right)right] \
4 & text{MultinormalDistribution}left[{0,0},left(
begin{array}{cc}
sigma ^2 & frac{sigma ^2}{4} \
frac{sigma ^2}{4} & frac{sigma ^2}{4} \
end{array}
right)right] \
5 & text{MultinormalDistribution}left[{0,0},left(
begin{array}{cc}
sigma ^2 & frac{sigma ^2}{5} \
frac{sigma ^2}{5} & frac{sigma ^2}{5} \
end{array}
right)right] \
6 & text{MultinormalDistribution}left[{0,0},left(
begin{array}{cc}
sigma ^2 & frac{sigma ^2}{6} \
frac{sigma ^2}{6} & frac{sigma ^2}{6} \
end{array}
right)right] \
7 & text{MultinormalDistribution}left[{0,0},left(
begin{array}{cc}
sigma ^2 & frac{sigma ^2}{7} \
frac{sigma ^2}{7} & frac{sigma ^2}{7} \
end{array}
right)right] \
8 & text{MultinormalDistribution}left[{0,0},left(
begin{array}{cc}
sigma ^2 & frac{sigma ^2}{8} \
frac{sigma ^2}{8} & frac{sigma ^2}{8} \
end{array}
right)right] \
9 & text{MultinormalDistribution}left[{0,0},left(
begin{array}{cc}
sigma ^2 & frac{sigma ^2}{9} \
frac{sigma ^2}{9} & frac{sigma ^2}{9} \
end{array}
right)right] \
10 & text{MultinormalDistribution}left[{0,0},left(
begin{array}{cc}
sigma ^2 & frac{sigma ^2}{10} \
frac{sigma ^2}{10} & frac{sigma ^2}{10} \
end{array}
right)right] \
end{array}
$$
So the general distribution is a multivariate normal
MultinormalDistribution[{0, 0}, {{σ^2, σ^2/n}, {σ^2/n, σ^2/n}}]
The general form of the joint density function can then be found with
FullSimplify[PDF[MultinormalDistribution[{0, 0}, {{σ^2, σ^2/n}, {σ^2/n, σ^2/n}}], {y, ybar}],
Assumptions -> {σ > 0, n > 1}]
$$frac{n e^{-frac{n left(n text{ybar}^2+y^2-2 y text{ybar}right)}{2 (n-1) sigma ^2}}}{2 pi sqrt{n-1} sigma ^2}$$
$endgroup$
$begingroup$
Anyway, I like your answer! I'll have to look at it to understand (not obvious (to me) that this would be the solution).
$endgroup$
– mjw
Mar 24 at 22:38
$begingroup$
@mjw Good. Answers should always be scrutinized and challenged if desired.
$endgroup$
– JimB
Mar 24 at 22:40
$begingroup$
Nice! In addition to trying to understand the technique, I checked the marginal integrals. Looks great!
$endgroup$
– mjw
Mar 25 at 1:13
add a comment |
$begingroup$
Here is the distribution of $x=overline{y}$ (Part I of your question):
a[n_] := Table[y[k] [Distributed] NormalDistribution[0, [Sigma]], {k, 1, n}];
p[n_] := TransformedDistribution[Sum[y[k]/n, {k, n}], a[n]];
Now
x [Distributed] p[5] (* n=5, for example *)
The result is
x [Distributed] NormalDistribution[0, Abs[[Sigma]]/Sqrt[5]]
$endgroup$
$begingroup$
I am not sure, but shouldn't be n instead of 5 hereTransformedDistribution[Sum[y[k]/n, {k, 5}], a]? And what if I want to leave n, without assigning a value to n? Thanks @mjw
$endgroup$
– Andrea2810
Mar 24 at 21:13
$begingroup$
Oh yes, you are right! I started with 10 and changed to five as I was trying it out. I'll fix it ... Thanks!
$endgroup$
– mjw
Mar 24 at 21:18
$begingroup$
Let's go with five because it is clearer. The result isNormalDistribution[0,[Sigma]/Sqrt[5]]. Not sure why Mathematica putsAbsaround $sigma$. Obviously, $sigma>0$.
$endgroup$
– mjw
Mar 24 at 21:22
$begingroup$
Yes, sure it is clearer. Do you have any idea of how can I use n as a parameter, without assigning a value to n?
$endgroup$
– Andrea2810
Mar 24 at 21:24
$begingroup$
a[n_] = Table[y[k] [Distributed] NormalDistribution[0, [Sigma]], {k, 1, n}];
$endgroup$
– mjw
Mar 24 at 21:25
|
show 5 more comments
$begingroup$
just modified @mjw's answer,
n = 100;(*for example*)ClearAll[y];
a = Table[y[k] [Distributed] NormalDistribution[0, [Sigma]], {k, 1, n}];
meanDist = TransformedDistribution[Sum[y[k]/100, {k, 100}], a]
JointDistribution can be composed by ProductDistribution,
if these random variables are independent.
if not,you have to use Copula
joint = ProductDistribution[meanDist,
Last@*List @@ Part[a, 1]] /. [Sigma] -> 1;
RandomVariate[joint, 100] // Histogram3D

joint = ProductDistribution[meanDist,
Last@*List @@ Part[a, 1]] /. [Sigma] -> 1;
m1 = RandomVariate[meanDist /. [Sigma] -> 1, {100000}];
m2 = RandomVariate[
Last@*List @@ Part[a, 1] /. [Sigma] -> 1, {100000}];
Correlation[Thread[List[m1, m2]]]
ListPlot[Thread[List[m1, m2]]]
=>
{{1., -0.00256777}, {-0.00256777, 1.}}

I'm not sure about correlation,but it's okay.
$endgroup$
$begingroup$
I believe that the distributions are not independent. Since $overline{x}$ is computed from $y_i$ and other $y_j$'s, it would seem to be dependent. We could compute whether or not the distributions are dependent ...
$endgroup$
– mjw
Mar 24 at 21:07
$begingroup$
I would also recommend using 10^6 rather than 100, you'll get a sharper plot!
$endgroup$
– mjw
Mar 24 at 21:15
$begingroup$
Exactly, the two variables are not independent unfortunately
$endgroup$
– Andrea2810
Mar 24 at 21:18
add a comment |
Your Answer
StackExchange.ifUsing("editor", function () {
return StackExchange.using("mathjaxEditing", function () {
StackExchange.MarkdownEditor.creationCallbacks.add(function (editor, postfix) {
StackExchange.mathjaxEditing.prepareWmdForMathJax(editor, postfix, [["$", "$"], ["\\(","\\)"]]);
});
});
}, "mathjax-editing");
StackExchange.ready(function() {
var channelOptions = {
tags: "".split(" "),
id: "387"
};
initTagRenderer("".split(" "), "".split(" "), channelOptions);
StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function() {
// Have to fire editor after snippets, if snippets enabled
if (StackExchange.settings.snippets.snippetsEnabled) {
StackExchange.using("snippets", function() {
createEditor();
});
}
else {
createEditor();
}
});
function createEditor() {
StackExchange.prepareEditor({
heartbeatType: 'answer',
autoActivateHeartbeat: false,
convertImagesToLinks: false,
noModals: true,
showLowRepImageUploadWarning: true,
reputationToPostImages: null,
bindNavPrevention: true,
postfix: "",
imageUploader: {
brandingHtml: "Powered by u003ca class="icon-imgur-white" href="https://imgur.com/"u003eu003c/au003e",
contentPolicyHtml: "User contributions licensed under u003ca href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/"u003ecc by-sa 3.0 with attribution requiredu003c/au003e u003ca href="https://stackoverflow.com/legal/content-policy"u003e(content policy)u003c/au003e",
allowUrls: true
},
onDemand: true,
discardSelector: ".discard-answer"
,immediatelyShowMarkdownHelp:true
});
}
});
Andrea2810 is a new contributor. Be nice, and check out our Code of Conduct.
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function () {
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fmathematica.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f193876%2ftransformation-of-random-variables-and-joint-distributions%23new-answer', 'question_page');
}
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
3 Answers
3
active
oldest
votes
3 Answers
3
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
$begingroup$
I don't know how to get Mathematica to get the joint distribution explicitly for a general value of $n$ but here is how one can easily see the pattern to figure out the general solution.
First the distribution of the mean:
marginalDistribution = TransformedDistribution[Sum[y[i], {i, n}]/n,
Table[y[i] [Distributed] NormalDistribution[0, [Sigma]], {i, n}],
Assumptions -> [Sigma] > 0]
{#, marginalDistribution/.n->#} &/@Range[2,10]
$$
begin{array}{cc}
2 & text{NormalDistribution}left[0,frac{sigma }{sqrt{2}}right] \
3 & text{NormalDistribution}left[0,frac{sigma }{sqrt{3}}right] \
4 & text{NormalDistribution}left[0,frac{sigma }{2}right] \
5 & text{NormalDistribution}left[0,frac{sigma }{sqrt{5}}right] \
6 & text{NormalDistribution}left[0,frac{sigma }{sqrt{6}}right] \
7 & text{NormalDistribution}left[0,frac{sigma }{sqrt{7}}right] \
8 & text{NormalDistribution}left[0,frac{sigma }{2 sqrt{2}}right] \
9 & text{NormalDistribution}left[0,frac{sigma }{3}right] \
10 & text{NormalDistribution}left[0,frac{sigma }{sqrt{10}}right] \
end{array}
$$
So we see that the marginal distribution of $bar{y}$ is
NormalDistribution[0, σ/Sqrt[n]]
The joint distribution of $bar{y}$ and, say, $y_1$ is given by
jointDistribution = TransformedDistribution[{y[1], Sum[y[i], {i, n}]/n},
Table[y[i] [Distributed] NormalDistribution[0, [Sigma]], {i, n}]]
{#, jointDistribution /. n -> #} & /@ Range[2, 10] // TableForm
$$
begin{array}{cc}
2 & text{MultinormalDistribution}left[{0,0},left(
begin{array}{cc}
sigma ^2 & frac{sigma ^2}{2} \
frac{sigma ^2}{2} & frac{sigma ^2}{2} \
end{array}
right)right] \
3 & text{MultinormalDistribution}left[{0,0},left(
begin{array}{cc}
sigma ^2 & frac{sigma ^2}{3} \
frac{sigma ^2}{3} & frac{sigma ^2}{3} \
end{array}
right)right] \
4 & text{MultinormalDistribution}left[{0,0},left(
begin{array}{cc}
sigma ^2 & frac{sigma ^2}{4} \
frac{sigma ^2}{4} & frac{sigma ^2}{4} \
end{array}
right)right] \
5 & text{MultinormalDistribution}left[{0,0},left(
begin{array}{cc}
sigma ^2 & frac{sigma ^2}{5} \
frac{sigma ^2}{5} & frac{sigma ^2}{5} \
end{array}
right)right] \
6 & text{MultinormalDistribution}left[{0,0},left(
begin{array}{cc}
sigma ^2 & frac{sigma ^2}{6} \
frac{sigma ^2}{6} & frac{sigma ^2}{6} \
end{array}
right)right] \
7 & text{MultinormalDistribution}left[{0,0},left(
begin{array}{cc}
sigma ^2 & frac{sigma ^2}{7} \
frac{sigma ^2}{7} & frac{sigma ^2}{7} \
end{array}
right)right] \
8 & text{MultinormalDistribution}left[{0,0},left(
begin{array}{cc}
sigma ^2 & frac{sigma ^2}{8} \
frac{sigma ^2}{8} & frac{sigma ^2}{8} \
end{array}
right)right] \
9 & text{MultinormalDistribution}left[{0,0},left(
begin{array}{cc}
sigma ^2 & frac{sigma ^2}{9} \
frac{sigma ^2}{9} & frac{sigma ^2}{9} \
end{array}
right)right] \
10 & text{MultinormalDistribution}left[{0,0},left(
begin{array}{cc}
sigma ^2 & frac{sigma ^2}{10} \
frac{sigma ^2}{10} & frac{sigma ^2}{10} \
end{array}
right)right] \
end{array}
$$
So the general distribution is a multivariate normal
MultinormalDistribution[{0, 0}, {{σ^2, σ^2/n}, {σ^2/n, σ^2/n}}]
The general form of the joint density function can then be found with
FullSimplify[PDF[MultinormalDistribution[{0, 0}, {{σ^2, σ^2/n}, {σ^2/n, σ^2/n}}], {y, ybar}],
Assumptions -> {σ > 0, n > 1}]
$$frac{n e^{-frac{n left(n text{ybar}^2+y^2-2 y text{ybar}right)}{2 (n-1) sigma ^2}}}{2 pi sqrt{n-1} sigma ^2}$$
$endgroup$
$begingroup$
Anyway, I like your answer! I'll have to look at it to understand (not obvious (to me) that this would be the solution).
$endgroup$
– mjw
Mar 24 at 22:38
$begingroup$
@mjw Good. Answers should always be scrutinized and challenged if desired.
$endgroup$
– JimB
Mar 24 at 22:40
$begingroup$
Nice! In addition to trying to understand the technique, I checked the marginal integrals. Looks great!
$endgroup$
– mjw
Mar 25 at 1:13
add a comment |
$begingroup$
I don't know how to get Mathematica to get the joint distribution explicitly for a general value of $n$ but here is how one can easily see the pattern to figure out the general solution.
First the distribution of the mean:
marginalDistribution = TransformedDistribution[Sum[y[i], {i, n}]/n,
Table[y[i] [Distributed] NormalDistribution[0, [Sigma]], {i, n}],
Assumptions -> [Sigma] > 0]
{#, marginalDistribution/.n->#} &/@Range[2,10]
$$
begin{array}{cc}
2 & text{NormalDistribution}left[0,frac{sigma }{sqrt{2}}right] \
3 & text{NormalDistribution}left[0,frac{sigma }{sqrt{3}}right] \
4 & text{NormalDistribution}left[0,frac{sigma }{2}right] \
5 & text{NormalDistribution}left[0,frac{sigma }{sqrt{5}}right] \
6 & text{NormalDistribution}left[0,frac{sigma }{sqrt{6}}right] \
7 & text{NormalDistribution}left[0,frac{sigma }{sqrt{7}}right] \
8 & text{NormalDistribution}left[0,frac{sigma }{2 sqrt{2}}right] \
9 & text{NormalDistribution}left[0,frac{sigma }{3}right] \
10 & text{NormalDistribution}left[0,frac{sigma }{sqrt{10}}right] \
end{array}
$$
So we see that the marginal distribution of $bar{y}$ is
NormalDistribution[0, σ/Sqrt[n]]
The joint distribution of $bar{y}$ and, say, $y_1$ is given by
jointDistribution = TransformedDistribution[{y[1], Sum[y[i], {i, n}]/n},
Table[y[i] [Distributed] NormalDistribution[0, [Sigma]], {i, n}]]
{#, jointDistribution /. n -> #} & /@ Range[2, 10] // TableForm
$$
begin{array}{cc}
2 & text{MultinormalDistribution}left[{0,0},left(
begin{array}{cc}
sigma ^2 & frac{sigma ^2}{2} \
frac{sigma ^2}{2} & frac{sigma ^2}{2} \
end{array}
right)right] \
3 & text{MultinormalDistribution}left[{0,0},left(
begin{array}{cc}
sigma ^2 & frac{sigma ^2}{3} \
frac{sigma ^2}{3} & frac{sigma ^2}{3} \
end{array}
right)right] \
4 & text{MultinormalDistribution}left[{0,0},left(
begin{array}{cc}
sigma ^2 & frac{sigma ^2}{4} \
frac{sigma ^2}{4} & frac{sigma ^2}{4} \
end{array}
right)right] \
5 & text{MultinormalDistribution}left[{0,0},left(
begin{array}{cc}
sigma ^2 & frac{sigma ^2}{5} \
frac{sigma ^2}{5} & frac{sigma ^2}{5} \
end{array}
right)right] \
6 & text{MultinormalDistribution}left[{0,0},left(
begin{array}{cc}
sigma ^2 & frac{sigma ^2}{6} \
frac{sigma ^2}{6} & frac{sigma ^2}{6} \
end{array}
right)right] \
7 & text{MultinormalDistribution}left[{0,0},left(
begin{array}{cc}
sigma ^2 & frac{sigma ^2}{7} \
frac{sigma ^2}{7} & frac{sigma ^2}{7} \
end{array}
right)right] \
8 & text{MultinormalDistribution}left[{0,0},left(
begin{array}{cc}
sigma ^2 & frac{sigma ^2}{8} \
frac{sigma ^2}{8} & frac{sigma ^2}{8} \
end{array}
right)right] \
9 & text{MultinormalDistribution}left[{0,0},left(
begin{array}{cc}
sigma ^2 & frac{sigma ^2}{9} \
frac{sigma ^2}{9} & frac{sigma ^2}{9} \
end{array}
right)right] \
10 & text{MultinormalDistribution}left[{0,0},left(
begin{array}{cc}
sigma ^2 & frac{sigma ^2}{10} \
frac{sigma ^2}{10} & frac{sigma ^2}{10} \
end{array}
right)right] \
end{array}
$$
So the general distribution is a multivariate normal
MultinormalDistribution[{0, 0}, {{σ^2, σ^2/n}, {σ^2/n, σ^2/n}}]
The general form of the joint density function can then be found with
FullSimplify[PDF[MultinormalDistribution[{0, 0}, {{σ^2, σ^2/n}, {σ^2/n, σ^2/n}}], {y, ybar}],
Assumptions -> {σ > 0, n > 1}]
$$frac{n e^{-frac{n left(n text{ybar}^2+y^2-2 y text{ybar}right)}{2 (n-1) sigma ^2}}}{2 pi sqrt{n-1} sigma ^2}$$
$endgroup$
$begingroup$
Anyway, I like your answer! I'll have to look at it to understand (not obvious (to me) that this would be the solution).
$endgroup$
– mjw
Mar 24 at 22:38
$begingroup$
@mjw Good. Answers should always be scrutinized and challenged if desired.
$endgroup$
– JimB
Mar 24 at 22:40
$begingroup$
Nice! In addition to trying to understand the technique, I checked the marginal integrals. Looks great!
$endgroup$
– mjw
Mar 25 at 1:13
add a comment |
$begingroup$
I don't know how to get Mathematica to get the joint distribution explicitly for a general value of $n$ but here is how one can easily see the pattern to figure out the general solution.
First the distribution of the mean:
marginalDistribution = TransformedDistribution[Sum[y[i], {i, n}]/n,
Table[y[i] [Distributed] NormalDistribution[0, [Sigma]], {i, n}],
Assumptions -> [Sigma] > 0]
{#, marginalDistribution/.n->#} &/@Range[2,10]
$$
begin{array}{cc}
2 & text{NormalDistribution}left[0,frac{sigma }{sqrt{2}}right] \
3 & text{NormalDistribution}left[0,frac{sigma }{sqrt{3}}right] \
4 & text{NormalDistribution}left[0,frac{sigma }{2}right] \
5 & text{NormalDistribution}left[0,frac{sigma }{sqrt{5}}right] \
6 & text{NormalDistribution}left[0,frac{sigma }{sqrt{6}}right] \
7 & text{NormalDistribution}left[0,frac{sigma }{sqrt{7}}right] \
8 & text{NormalDistribution}left[0,frac{sigma }{2 sqrt{2}}right] \
9 & text{NormalDistribution}left[0,frac{sigma }{3}right] \
10 & text{NormalDistribution}left[0,frac{sigma }{sqrt{10}}right] \
end{array}
$$
So we see that the marginal distribution of $bar{y}$ is
NormalDistribution[0, σ/Sqrt[n]]
The joint distribution of $bar{y}$ and, say, $y_1$ is given by
jointDistribution = TransformedDistribution[{y[1], Sum[y[i], {i, n}]/n},
Table[y[i] [Distributed] NormalDistribution[0, [Sigma]], {i, n}]]
{#, jointDistribution /. n -> #} & /@ Range[2, 10] // TableForm
$$
begin{array}{cc}
2 & text{MultinormalDistribution}left[{0,0},left(
begin{array}{cc}
sigma ^2 & frac{sigma ^2}{2} \
frac{sigma ^2}{2} & frac{sigma ^2}{2} \
end{array}
right)right] \
3 & text{MultinormalDistribution}left[{0,0},left(
begin{array}{cc}
sigma ^2 & frac{sigma ^2}{3} \
frac{sigma ^2}{3} & frac{sigma ^2}{3} \
end{array}
right)right] \
4 & text{MultinormalDistribution}left[{0,0},left(
begin{array}{cc}
sigma ^2 & frac{sigma ^2}{4} \
frac{sigma ^2}{4} & frac{sigma ^2}{4} \
end{array}
right)right] \
5 & text{MultinormalDistribution}left[{0,0},left(
begin{array}{cc}
sigma ^2 & frac{sigma ^2}{5} \
frac{sigma ^2}{5} & frac{sigma ^2}{5} \
end{array}
right)right] \
6 & text{MultinormalDistribution}left[{0,0},left(
begin{array}{cc}
sigma ^2 & frac{sigma ^2}{6} \
frac{sigma ^2}{6} & frac{sigma ^2}{6} \
end{array}
right)right] \
7 & text{MultinormalDistribution}left[{0,0},left(
begin{array}{cc}
sigma ^2 & frac{sigma ^2}{7} \
frac{sigma ^2}{7} & frac{sigma ^2}{7} \
end{array}
right)right] \
8 & text{MultinormalDistribution}left[{0,0},left(
begin{array}{cc}
sigma ^2 & frac{sigma ^2}{8} \
frac{sigma ^2}{8} & frac{sigma ^2}{8} \
end{array}
right)right] \
9 & text{MultinormalDistribution}left[{0,0},left(
begin{array}{cc}
sigma ^2 & frac{sigma ^2}{9} \
frac{sigma ^2}{9} & frac{sigma ^2}{9} \
end{array}
right)right] \
10 & text{MultinormalDistribution}left[{0,0},left(
begin{array}{cc}
sigma ^2 & frac{sigma ^2}{10} \
frac{sigma ^2}{10} & frac{sigma ^2}{10} \
end{array}
right)right] \
end{array}
$$
So the general distribution is a multivariate normal
MultinormalDistribution[{0, 0}, {{σ^2, σ^2/n}, {σ^2/n, σ^2/n}}]
The general form of the joint density function can then be found with
FullSimplify[PDF[MultinormalDistribution[{0, 0}, {{σ^2, σ^2/n}, {σ^2/n, σ^2/n}}], {y, ybar}],
Assumptions -> {σ > 0, n > 1}]
$$frac{n e^{-frac{n left(n text{ybar}^2+y^2-2 y text{ybar}right)}{2 (n-1) sigma ^2}}}{2 pi sqrt{n-1} sigma ^2}$$
$endgroup$
I don't know how to get Mathematica to get the joint distribution explicitly for a general value of $n$ but here is how one can easily see the pattern to figure out the general solution.
First the distribution of the mean:
marginalDistribution = TransformedDistribution[Sum[y[i], {i, n}]/n,
Table[y[i] [Distributed] NormalDistribution[0, [Sigma]], {i, n}],
Assumptions -> [Sigma] > 0]
{#, marginalDistribution/.n->#} &/@Range[2,10]
$$
begin{array}{cc}
2 & text{NormalDistribution}left[0,frac{sigma }{sqrt{2}}right] \
3 & text{NormalDistribution}left[0,frac{sigma }{sqrt{3}}right] \
4 & text{NormalDistribution}left[0,frac{sigma }{2}right] \
5 & text{NormalDistribution}left[0,frac{sigma }{sqrt{5}}right] \
6 & text{NormalDistribution}left[0,frac{sigma }{sqrt{6}}right] \
7 & text{NormalDistribution}left[0,frac{sigma }{sqrt{7}}right] \
8 & text{NormalDistribution}left[0,frac{sigma }{2 sqrt{2}}right] \
9 & text{NormalDistribution}left[0,frac{sigma }{3}right] \
10 & text{NormalDistribution}left[0,frac{sigma }{sqrt{10}}right] \
end{array}
$$
So we see that the marginal distribution of $bar{y}$ is
NormalDistribution[0, σ/Sqrt[n]]
The joint distribution of $bar{y}$ and, say, $y_1$ is given by
jointDistribution = TransformedDistribution[{y[1], Sum[y[i], {i, n}]/n},
Table[y[i] [Distributed] NormalDistribution[0, [Sigma]], {i, n}]]
{#, jointDistribution /. n -> #} & /@ Range[2, 10] // TableForm
$$
begin{array}{cc}
2 & text{MultinormalDistribution}left[{0,0},left(
begin{array}{cc}
sigma ^2 & frac{sigma ^2}{2} \
frac{sigma ^2}{2} & frac{sigma ^2}{2} \
end{array}
right)right] \
3 & text{MultinormalDistribution}left[{0,0},left(
begin{array}{cc}
sigma ^2 & frac{sigma ^2}{3} \
frac{sigma ^2}{3} & frac{sigma ^2}{3} \
end{array}
right)right] \
4 & text{MultinormalDistribution}left[{0,0},left(
begin{array}{cc}
sigma ^2 & frac{sigma ^2}{4} \
frac{sigma ^2}{4} & frac{sigma ^2}{4} \
end{array}
right)right] \
5 & text{MultinormalDistribution}left[{0,0},left(
begin{array}{cc}
sigma ^2 & frac{sigma ^2}{5} \
frac{sigma ^2}{5} & frac{sigma ^2}{5} \
end{array}
right)right] \
6 & text{MultinormalDistribution}left[{0,0},left(
begin{array}{cc}
sigma ^2 & frac{sigma ^2}{6} \
frac{sigma ^2}{6} & frac{sigma ^2}{6} \
end{array}
right)right] \
7 & text{MultinormalDistribution}left[{0,0},left(
begin{array}{cc}
sigma ^2 & frac{sigma ^2}{7} \
frac{sigma ^2}{7} & frac{sigma ^2}{7} \
end{array}
right)right] \
8 & text{MultinormalDistribution}left[{0,0},left(
begin{array}{cc}
sigma ^2 & frac{sigma ^2}{8} \
frac{sigma ^2}{8} & frac{sigma ^2}{8} \
end{array}
right)right] \
9 & text{MultinormalDistribution}left[{0,0},left(
begin{array}{cc}
sigma ^2 & frac{sigma ^2}{9} \
frac{sigma ^2}{9} & frac{sigma ^2}{9} \
end{array}
right)right] \
10 & text{MultinormalDistribution}left[{0,0},left(
begin{array}{cc}
sigma ^2 & frac{sigma ^2}{10} \
frac{sigma ^2}{10} & frac{sigma ^2}{10} \
end{array}
right)right] \
end{array}
$$
So the general distribution is a multivariate normal
MultinormalDistribution[{0, 0}, {{σ^2, σ^2/n}, {σ^2/n, σ^2/n}}]
The general form of the joint density function can then be found with
FullSimplify[PDF[MultinormalDistribution[{0, 0}, {{σ^2, σ^2/n}, {σ^2/n, σ^2/n}}], {y, ybar}],
Assumptions -> {σ > 0, n > 1}]
$$frac{n e^{-frac{n left(n text{ybar}^2+y^2-2 y text{ybar}right)}{2 (n-1) sigma ^2}}}{2 pi sqrt{n-1} sigma ^2}$$
edited Mar 24 at 22:28
answered Mar 24 at 22:20
JimBJimB
18.2k12863
18.2k12863
$begingroup$
Anyway, I like your answer! I'll have to look at it to understand (not obvious (to me) that this would be the solution).
$endgroup$
– mjw
Mar 24 at 22:38
$begingroup$
@mjw Good. Answers should always be scrutinized and challenged if desired.
$endgroup$
– JimB
Mar 24 at 22:40
$begingroup$
Nice! In addition to trying to understand the technique, I checked the marginal integrals. Looks great!
$endgroup$
– mjw
Mar 25 at 1:13
add a comment |
$begingroup$
Anyway, I like your answer! I'll have to look at it to understand (not obvious (to me) that this would be the solution).
$endgroup$
– mjw
Mar 24 at 22:38
$begingroup$
@mjw Good. Answers should always be scrutinized and challenged if desired.
$endgroup$
– JimB
Mar 24 at 22:40
$begingroup$
Nice! In addition to trying to understand the technique, I checked the marginal integrals. Looks great!
$endgroup$
– mjw
Mar 25 at 1:13
$begingroup$
Anyway, I like your answer! I'll have to look at it to understand (not obvious (to me) that this would be the solution).
$endgroup$
– mjw
Mar 24 at 22:38
$begingroup$
Anyway, I like your answer! I'll have to look at it to understand (not obvious (to me) that this would be the solution).
$endgroup$
– mjw
Mar 24 at 22:38
$begingroup$
@mjw Good. Answers should always be scrutinized and challenged if desired.
$endgroup$
– JimB
Mar 24 at 22:40
$begingroup$
@mjw Good. Answers should always be scrutinized and challenged if desired.
$endgroup$
– JimB
Mar 24 at 22:40
$begingroup$
Nice! In addition to trying to understand the technique, I checked the marginal integrals. Looks great!
$endgroup$
– mjw
Mar 25 at 1:13
$begingroup$
Nice! In addition to trying to understand the technique, I checked the marginal integrals. Looks great!
$endgroup$
– mjw
Mar 25 at 1:13
add a comment |
$begingroup$
Here is the distribution of $x=overline{y}$ (Part I of your question):
a[n_] := Table[y[k] [Distributed] NormalDistribution[0, [Sigma]], {k, 1, n}];
p[n_] := TransformedDistribution[Sum[y[k]/n, {k, n}], a[n]];
Now
x [Distributed] p[5] (* n=5, for example *)
The result is
x [Distributed] NormalDistribution[0, Abs[[Sigma]]/Sqrt[5]]
$endgroup$
$begingroup$
I am not sure, but shouldn't be n instead of 5 hereTransformedDistribution[Sum[y[k]/n, {k, 5}], a]? And what if I want to leave n, without assigning a value to n? Thanks @mjw
$endgroup$
– Andrea2810
Mar 24 at 21:13
$begingroup$
Oh yes, you are right! I started with 10 and changed to five as I was trying it out. I'll fix it ... Thanks!
$endgroup$
– mjw
Mar 24 at 21:18
$begingroup$
Let's go with five because it is clearer. The result isNormalDistribution[0,[Sigma]/Sqrt[5]]. Not sure why Mathematica putsAbsaround $sigma$. Obviously, $sigma>0$.
$endgroup$
– mjw
Mar 24 at 21:22
$begingroup$
Yes, sure it is clearer. Do you have any idea of how can I use n as a parameter, without assigning a value to n?
$endgroup$
– Andrea2810
Mar 24 at 21:24
$begingroup$
a[n_] = Table[y[k] [Distributed] NormalDistribution[0, [Sigma]], {k, 1, n}];
$endgroup$
– mjw
Mar 24 at 21:25
|
show 5 more comments
$begingroup$
Here is the distribution of $x=overline{y}$ (Part I of your question):
a[n_] := Table[y[k] [Distributed] NormalDistribution[0, [Sigma]], {k, 1, n}];
p[n_] := TransformedDistribution[Sum[y[k]/n, {k, n}], a[n]];
Now
x [Distributed] p[5] (* n=5, for example *)
The result is
x [Distributed] NormalDistribution[0, Abs[[Sigma]]/Sqrt[5]]
$endgroup$
$begingroup$
I am not sure, but shouldn't be n instead of 5 hereTransformedDistribution[Sum[y[k]/n, {k, 5}], a]? And what if I want to leave n, without assigning a value to n? Thanks @mjw
$endgroup$
– Andrea2810
Mar 24 at 21:13
$begingroup$
Oh yes, you are right! I started with 10 and changed to five as I was trying it out. I'll fix it ... Thanks!
$endgroup$
– mjw
Mar 24 at 21:18
$begingroup$
Let's go with five because it is clearer. The result isNormalDistribution[0,[Sigma]/Sqrt[5]]. Not sure why Mathematica putsAbsaround $sigma$. Obviously, $sigma>0$.
$endgroup$
– mjw
Mar 24 at 21:22
$begingroup$
Yes, sure it is clearer. Do you have any idea of how can I use n as a parameter, without assigning a value to n?
$endgroup$
– Andrea2810
Mar 24 at 21:24
$begingroup$
a[n_] = Table[y[k] [Distributed] NormalDistribution[0, [Sigma]], {k, 1, n}];
$endgroup$
– mjw
Mar 24 at 21:25
|
show 5 more comments
$begingroup$
Here is the distribution of $x=overline{y}$ (Part I of your question):
a[n_] := Table[y[k] [Distributed] NormalDistribution[0, [Sigma]], {k, 1, n}];
p[n_] := TransformedDistribution[Sum[y[k]/n, {k, n}], a[n]];
Now
x [Distributed] p[5] (* n=5, for example *)
The result is
x [Distributed] NormalDistribution[0, Abs[[Sigma]]/Sqrt[5]]
$endgroup$
Here is the distribution of $x=overline{y}$ (Part I of your question):
a[n_] := Table[y[k] [Distributed] NormalDistribution[0, [Sigma]], {k, 1, n}];
p[n_] := TransformedDistribution[Sum[y[k]/n, {k, n}], a[n]];
Now
x [Distributed] p[5] (* n=5, for example *)
The result is
x [Distributed] NormalDistribution[0, Abs[[Sigma]]/Sqrt[5]]
edited Mar 25 at 1:14
answered Mar 24 at 20:10
mjwmjw
1,11910
1,11910
$begingroup$
I am not sure, but shouldn't be n instead of 5 hereTransformedDistribution[Sum[y[k]/n, {k, 5}], a]? And what if I want to leave n, without assigning a value to n? Thanks @mjw
$endgroup$
– Andrea2810
Mar 24 at 21:13
$begingroup$
Oh yes, you are right! I started with 10 and changed to five as I was trying it out. I'll fix it ... Thanks!
$endgroup$
– mjw
Mar 24 at 21:18
$begingroup$
Let's go with five because it is clearer. The result isNormalDistribution[0,[Sigma]/Sqrt[5]]. Not sure why Mathematica putsAbsaround $sigma$. Obviously, $sigma>0$.
$endgroup$
– mjw
Mar 24 at 21:22
$begingroup$
Yes, sure it is clearer. Do you have any idea of how can I use n as a parameter, without assigning a value to n?
$endgroup$
– Andrea2810
Mar 24 at 21:24
$begingroup$
a[n_] = Table[y[k] [Distributed] NormalDistribution[0, [Sigma]], {k, 1, n}];
$endgroup$
– mjw
Mar 24 at 21:25
|
show 5 more comments
$begingroup$
I am not sure, but shouldn't be n instead of 5 hereTransformedDistribution[Sum[y[k]/n, {k, 5}], a]? And what if I want to leave n, without assigning a value to n? Thanks @mjw
$endgroup$
– Andrea2810
Mar 24 at 21:13
$begingroup$
Oh yes, you are right! I started with 10 and changed to five as I was trying it out. I'll fix it ... Thanks!
$endgroup$
– mjw
Mar 24 at 21:18
$begingroup$
Let's go with five because it is clearer. The result isNormalDistribution[0,[Sigma]/Sqrt[5]]. Not sure why Mathematica putsAbsaround $sigma$. Obviously, $sigma>0$.
$endgroup$
– mjw
Mar 24 at 21:22
$begingroup$
Yes, sure it is clearer. Do you have any idea of how can I use n as a parameter, without assigning a value to n?
$endgroup$
– Andrea2810
Mar 24 at 21:24
$begingroup$
a[n_] = Table[y[k] [Distributed] NormalDistribution[0, [Sigma]], {k, 1, n}];
$endgroup$
– mjw
Mar 24 at 21:25
$begingroup$
I am not sure, but shouldn't be n instead of 5 here
TransformedDistribution[Sum[y[k]/n, {k, 5}], a] ? And what if I want to leave n, without assigning a value to n? Thanks @mjw$endgroup$
– Andrea2810
Mar 24 at 21:13
$begingroup$
I am not sure, but shouldn't be n instead of 5 here
TransformedDistribution[Sum[y[k]/n, {k, 5}], a] ? And what if I want to leave n, without assigning a value to n? Thanks @mjw$endgroup$
– Andrea2810
Mar 24 at 21:13
$begingroup$
Oh yes, you are right! I started with 10 and changed to five as I was trying it out. I'll fix it ... Thanks!
$endgroup$
– mjw
Mar 24 at 21:18
$begingroup$
Oh yes, you are right! I started with 10 and changed to five as I was trying it out. I'll fix it ... Thanks!
$endgroup$
– mjw
Mar 24 at 21:18
$begingroup$
Let's go with five because it is clearer. The result is
NormalDistribution[0,[Sigma]/Sqrt[5]]. Not sure why Mathematica puts Abs around $sigma$. Obviously, $sigma>0$.$endgroup$
– mjw
Mar 24 at 21:22
$begingroup$
Let's go with five because it is clearer. The result is
NormalDistribution[0,[Sigma]/Sqrt[5]]. Not sure why Mathematica puts Abs around $sigma$. Obviously, $sigma>0$.$endgroup$
– mjw
Mar 24 at 21:22
$begingroup$
Yes, sure it is clearer. Do you have any idea of how can I use n as a parameter, without assigning a value to n?
$endgroup$
– Andrea2810
Mar 24 at 21:24
$begingroup$
Yes, sure it is clearer. Do you have any idea of how can I use n as a parameter, without assigning a value to n?
$endgroup$
– Andrea2810
Mar 24 at 21:24
$begingroup$
a[n_] = Table[y[k] [Distributed] NormalDistribution[0, [Sigma]], {k, 1, n}];$endgroup$
– mjw
Mar 24 at 21:25
$begingroup$
a[n_] = Table[y[k] [Distributed] NormalDistribution[0, [Sigma]], {k, 1, n}];$endgroup$
– mjw
Mar 24 at 21:25
|
show 5 more comments
$begingroup$
just modified @mjw's answer,
n = 100;(*for example*)ClearAll[y];
a = Table[y[k] [Distributed] NormalDistribution[0, [Sigma]], {k, 1, n}];
meanDist = TransformedDistribution[Sum[y[k]/100, {k, 100}], a]
JointDistribution can be composed by ProductDistribution,
if these random variables are independent.
if not,you have to use Copula
joint = ProductDistribution[meanDist,
Last@*List @@ Part[a, 1]] /. [Sigma] -> 1;
RandomVariate[joint, 100] // Histogram3D

joint = ProductDistribution[meanDist,
Last@*List @@ Part[a, 1]] /. [Sigma] -> 1;
m1 = RandomVariate[meanDist /. [Sigma] -> 1, {100000}];
m2 = RandomVariate[
Last@*List @@ Part[a, 1] /. [Sigma] -> 1, {100000}];
Correlation[Thread[List[m1, m2]]]
ListPlot[Thread[List[m1, m2]]]
=>
{{1., -0.00256777}, {-0.00256777, 1.}}

I'm not sure about correlation,but it's okay.
$endgroup$
$begingroup$
I believe that the distributions are not independent. Since $overline{x}$ is computed from $y_i$ and other $y_j$'s, it would seem to be dependent. We could compute whether or not the distributions are dependent ...
$endgroup$
– mjw
Mar 24 at 21:07
$begingroup$
I would also recommend using 10^6 rather than 100, you'll get a sharper plot!
$endgroup$
– mjw
Mar 24 at 21:15
$begingroup$
Exactly, the two variables are not independent unfortunately
$endgroup$
– Andrea2810
Mar 24 at 21:18
add a comment |
$begingroup$
just modified @mjw's answer,
n = 100;(*for example*)ClearAll[y];
a = Table[y[k] [Distributed] NormalDistribution[0, [Sigma]], {k, 1, n}];
meanDist = TransformedDistribution[Sum[y[k]/100, {k, 100}], a]
JointDistribution can be composed by ProductDistribution,
if these random variables are independent.
if not,you have to use Copula
joint = ProductDistribution[meanDist,
Last@*List @@ Part[a, 1]] /. [Sigma] -> 1;
RandomVariate[joint, 100] // Histogram3D

joint = ProductDistribution[meanDist,
Last@*List @@ Part[a, 1]] /. [Sigma] -> 1;
m1 = RandomVariate[meanDist /. [Sigma] -> 1, {100000}];
m2 = RandomVariate[
Last@*List @@ Part[a, 1] /. [Sigma] -> 1, {100000}];
Correlation[Thread[List[m1, m2]]]
ListPlot[Thread[List[m1, m2]]]
=>
{{1., -0.00256777}, {-0.00256777, 1.}}

I'm not sure about correlation,but it's okay.
$endgroup$
$begingroup$
I believe that the distributions are not independent. Since $overline{x}$ is computed from $y_i$ and other $y_j$'s, it would seem to be dependent. We could compute whether or not the distributions are dependent ...
$endgroup$
– mjw
Mar 24 at 21:07
$begingroup$
I would also recommend using 10^6 rather than 100, you'll get a sharper plot!
$endgroup$
– mjw
Mar 24 at 21:15
$begingroup$
Exactly, the two variables are not independent unfortunately
$endgroup$
– Andrea2810
Mar 24 at 21:18
add a comment |
$begingroup$
just modified @mjw's answer,
n = 100;(*for example*)ClearAll[y];
a = Table[y[k] [Distributed] NormalDistribution[0, [Sigma]], {k, 1, n}];
meanDist = TransformedDistribution[Sum[y[k]/100, {k, 100}], a]
JointDistribution can be composed by ProductDistribution,
if these random variables are independent.
if not,you have to use Copula
joint = ProductDistribution[meanDist,
Last@*List @@ Part[a, 1]] /. [Sigma] -> 1;
RandomVariate[joint, 100] // Histogram3D

joint = ProductDistribution[meanDist,
Last@*List @@ Part[a, 1]] /. [Sigma] -> 1;
m1 = RandomVariate[meanDist /. [Sigma] -> 1, {100000}];
m2 = RandomVariate[
Last@*List @@ Part[a, 1] /. [Sigma] -> 1, {100000}];
Correlation[Thread[List[m1, m2]]]
ListPlot[Thread[List[m1, m2]]]
=>
{{1., -0.00256777}, {-0.00256777, 1.}}

I'm not sure about correlation,but it's okay.
$endgroup$
just modified @mjw's answer,
n = 100;(*for example*)ClearAll[y];
a = Table[y[k] [Distributed] NormalDistribution[0, [Sigma]], {k, 1, n}];
meanDist = TransformedDistribution[Sum[y[k]/100, {k, 100}], a]
JointDistribution can be composed by ProductDistribution,
if these random variables are independent.
if not,you have to use Copula
joint = ProductDistribution[meanDist,
Last@*List @@ Part[a, 1]] /. [Sigma] -> 1;
RandomVariate[joint, 100] // Histogram3D

joint = ProductDistribution[meanDist,
Last@*List @@ Part[a, 1]] /. [Sigma] -> 1;
m1 = RandomVariate[meanDist /. [Sigma] -> 1, {100000}];
m2 = RandomVariate[
Last@*List @@ Part[a, 1] /. [Sigma] -> 1, {100000}];
Correlation[Thread[List[m1, m2]]]
ListPlot[Thread[List[m1, m2]]]
=>
{{1., -0.00256777}, {-0.00256777, 1.}}

I'm not sure about correlation,but it's okay.
edited Mar 24 at 21:49
answered Mar 24 at 20:34
XminerXminer
34118
34118
$begingroup$
I believe that the distributions are not independent. Since $overline{x}$ is computed from $y_i$ and other $y_j$'s, it would seem to be dependent. We could compute whether or not the distributions are dependent ...
$endgroup$
– mjw
Mar 24 at 21:07
$begingroup$
I would also recommend using 10^6 rather than 100, you'll get a sharper plot!
$endgroup$
– mjw
Mar 24 at 21:15
$begingroup$
Exactly, the two variables are not independent unfortunately
$endgroup$
– Andrea2810
Mar 24 at 21:18
add a comment |
$begingroup$
I believe that the distributions are not independent. Since $overline{x}$ is computed from $y_i$ and other $y_j$'s, it would seem to be dependent. We could compute whether or not the distributions are dependent ...
$endgroup$
– mjw
Mar 24 at 21:07
$begingroup$
I would also recommend using 10^6 rather than 100, you'll get a sharper plot!
$endgroup$
– mjw
Mar 24 at 21:15
$begingroup$
Exactly, the two variables are not independent unfortunately
$endgroup$
– Andrea2810
Mar 24 at 21:18
$begingroup$
I believe that the distributions are not independent. Since $overline{x}$ is computed from $y_i$ and other $y_j$'s, it would seem to be dependent. We could compute whether or not the distributions are dependent ...
$endgroup$
– mjw
Mar 24 at 21:07
$begingroup$
I believe that the distributions are not independent. Since $overline{x}$ is computed from $y_i$ and other $y_j$'s, it would seem to be dependent. We could compute whether or not the distributions are dependent ...
$endgroup$
– mjw
Mar 24 at 21:07
$begingroup$
I would also recommend using 10^6 rather than 100, you'll get a sharper plot!
$endgroup$
– mjw
Mar 24 at 21:15
$begingroup$
I would also recommend using 10^6 rather than 100, you'll get a sharper plot!
$endgroup$
– mjw
Mar 24 at 21:15
$begingroup$
Exactly, the two variables are not independent unfortunately
$endgroup$
– Andrea2810
Mar 24 at 21:18
$begingroup$
Exactly, the two variables are not independent unfortunately
$endgroup$
– Andrea2810
Mar 24 at 21:18
add a comment |
Andrea2810 is a new contributor. Be nice, and check out our Code of Conduct.
Andrea2810 is a new contributor. Be nice, and check out our Code of Conduct.
Andrea2810 is a new contributor. Be nice, and check out our Code of Conduct.
Andrea2810 is a new contributor. Be nice, and check out our Code of Conduct.
Thanks for contributing an answer to Mathematica Stack Exchange!
- Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!
But avoid …
- Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.
- Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.
Use MathJax to format equations. MathJax reference.
To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function () {
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fmathematica.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f193876%2ftransformation-of-random-variables-and-joint-distributions%23new-answer', 'question_page');
}
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
5
$begingroup$
What have you tried? For example, have you seen the documentation on
TransformedDistributionandProbabilityDistribution?$endgroup$
– JimB
Mar 24 at 16:58
$begingroup$
@JimB . I tried this
TransformedDistribution[Sum[y, {i, n}]/n, y [Distributed] NormalDistribution[0, [Sigma]y]]. The result isNormalDistribution[0, [Sigma]y]. However, the correct result should beNormalDistribution[0, [Sigma]y / Sqrt[n]]$endgroup$
– Andrea2810
Mar 24 at 17:42
1
$begingroup$
You need to "index" the variable
yor else Mathematica thinks it is a single variable.$endgroup$
– JimB
Mar 24 at 22:04