Can I make an object, so that when the characters touch it they are teleported somewhere else?
up vote
10
down vote
favorite
I want it so I can teleport characters to the top of a tower in D&D 5e. They will then battle their way down the tower. My idea is that they touch an object and it teleports them there. Is this a thing, or is there a better way of doing this?
I want to use this for an idea I have for a 1 off adventure: the party is told that farm animals are going missing. They find out it's from a teleport masked as an item (I haven’t decided what item). They use the item to teleport to where they are going, find they are food for a tower of orcs. They fight the orcs and face a wizard at the end who made the teleport item.
dnd-5e teleportation plot
New contributor
add a comment |
up vote
10
down vote
favorite
I want it so I can teleport characters to the top of a tower in D&D 5e. They will then battle their way down the tower. My idea is that they touch an object and it teleports them there. Is this a thing, or is there a better way of doing this?
I want to use this for an idea I have for a 1 off adventure: the party is told that farm animals are going missing. They find out it's from a teleport masked as an item (I haven’t decided what item). They use the item to teleport to where they are going, find they are food for a tower of orcs. They fight the orcs and face a wizard at the end who made the teleport item.
dnd-5e teleportation plot
New contributor
2
@enkryptor Editing the question like that would assume that the answer is already “you can only do this with spell X” — which defeats the purpose of asking, and suggesting such an edit assumes that is the answer, when it is not necessarily. So no, it’s not necessary to edit the question to specify that it works like spell X.
– SevenSidedDie♦
Nov 24 at 17:11
add a comment |
up vote
10
down vote
favorite
up vote
10
down vote
favorite
I want it so I can teleport characters to the top of a tower in D&D 5e. They will then battle their way down the tower. My idea is that they touch an object and it teleports them there. Is this a thing, or is there a better way of doing this?
I want to use this for an idea I have for a 1 off adventure: the party is told that farm animals are going missing. They find out it's from a teleport masked as an item (I haven’t decided what item). They use the item to teleport to where they are going, find they are food for a tower of orcs. They fight the orcs and face a wizard at the end who made the teleport item.
dnd-5e teleportation plot
New contributor
I want it so I can teleport characters to the top of a tower in D&D 5e. They will then battle their way down the tower. My idea is that they touch an object and it teleports them there. Is this a thing, or is there a better way of doing this?
I want to use this for an idea I have for a 1 off adventure: the party is told that farm animals are going missing. They find out it's from a teleport masked as an item (I haven’t decided what item). They use the item to teleport to where they are going, find they are food for a tower of orcs. They fight the orcs and face a wizard at the end who made the teleport item.
dnd-5e teleportation plot
dnd-5e teleportation plot
New contributor
New contributor
edited Nov 24 at 17:16
SevenSidedDie♦
203k27648927
203k27648927
New contributor
asked Nov 24 at 11:43
George
543
543
New contributor
New contributor
2
@enkryptor Editing the question like that would assume that the answer is already “you can only do this with spell X” — which defeats the purpose of asking, and suggesting such an edit assumes that is the answer, when it is not necessarily. So no, it’s not necessary to edit the question to specify that it works like spell X.
– SevenSidedDie♦
Nov 24 at 17:11
add a comment |
2
@enkryptor Editing the question like that would assume that the answer is already “you can only do this with spell X” — which defeats the purpose of asking, and suggesting such an edit assumes that is the answer, when it is not necessarily. So no, it’s not necessary to edit the question to specify that it works like spell X.
– SevenSidedDie♦
Nov 24 at 17:11
2
2
@enkryptor Editing the question like that would assume that the answer is already “you can only do this with spell X” — which defeats the purpose of asking, and suggesting such an edit assumes that is the answer, when it is not necessarily. So no, it’s not necessary to edit the question to specify that it works like spell X.
– SevenSidedDie♦
Nov 24 at 17:11
@enkryptor Editing the question like that would assume that the answer is already “you can only do this with spell X” — which defeats the purpose of asking, and suggesting such an edit assumes that is the answer, when it is not necessarily. So no, it’s not necessary to edit the question to specify that it works like spell X.
– SevenSidedDie♦
Nov 24 at 17:11
add a comment |
4 Answers
4
active
oldest
votes
up vote
22
down vote
Short Answer: Yes, you can.
I'm not familiar with the D&D5 rules in particular, but even if there wouldn't be any mention of a teleporting item or spell, nothing prevents you as a GM from making it up for your table or specific campaign.
The same goes for any limitations on existing items. If it doesn't exactly work the way you need by the rules, you can just houserule it to do so.
add a comment |
up vote
8
down vote
Glyph of Warding
Have an NPC wizard cast glyph of warding, along with teleportation circle spell as the stored spell, declaring the top of the tower as your destination. Specify your trigger "when a creature touch this glyph/object".
Of course, PC can also do this.
Note: You can use teleport instead of teleportation circle, but teleportation circle is far superior.
teleport requires the triggering creature to be "willing". Your DM may rule that the triggering creature is not willing, thus wasting your spell.
teleport can only target the triggering creature, because the glyph of warding requires the stored spell to target a single creature or an area.
teleport is a 7th level spell, while teleportation circle is a 5th level one. You have access to teleportation circle earlier, and will only need 5th level spell slot instead of 7th.
teleport has a chance to fail, even when teleporting to a permanent magic circle. If you need a reliable method, teleportation circle is better.
Some also argues that teleportation circle is not a valid spell for glyph of warding, you can learn more about that from this question: Glyph of Warding and Teleportation Circle
2
-1, because teleportation circle doesn't just snatch people up. It creates a portal the person has to walk through: "A shimmering portal opens within the circle you drew and remains open until the end of your next turn. Any creature that enters the portal instantly appears within 5 feet of the destination circle or in the nearest unoccupied space if that space is occupied."
– T.J.L.
Nov 26 at 13:47
add a comment |
up vote
4
down vote
Yes, you can absolutely do this
As others have mentioned there is significant GM Fiat to create such creations in D&D 5e.
Note: the rest of this answer contains spoilers for a portion of a published adventure.
You might want to take some inspiration from the adventure
Waterdeep: Dungeon of the Mad Mage.
In that adventure:
On level 15 (p. 194), the concept of a Teleport Trap is introduced that has the following effect:
A creature that enters the trap’s space is teleported along with any objects it is wearing or carrying to another teleport trap (or the nearest unoccupied space). There is no saving throw to resist the teleportation effect, and the destination varies from trap to trap. Once a creature has been teleported in this way, it is unaffected by teleport traps on this level for 1 hour.
When a creature is teleported by a trap, Halaster’s booming voice shouts “Teleported!” in Common. The magical voice originates at the point of departure and the point of arrival, and it is audible in both locations out to a range of 100 feet.
Some teleport traps have additional effects, as described in their encounter locations.
There is some additional information in the adventure, including
details on placement of the traps and some important DCs for PCs finding them.
It also has this highlighted note on the intended effect of the teleportation traps:
Splitting the Party. Teleport traps are designed to split the party [...]
The idea of a voice-over taunt/quote when a trap is triggered sounds hilarious.
– V2Blast
Nov 25 at 18:58
@V2Blast I like the idea of it alright...will be a while before I get to spring it one my players though
– illustro
Nov 26 at 10:07
add a comment |
up vote
2
down vote
In a lot of D&D-like systems, there's the concept of a 'teleport trap', which is almost exactly what you're asking for. The first example that comes to my mind is the teleport traps in Nethack, which will send you randomly to a different location on the same floor, or possibly to a different floor for specific types, when you step on a specific square.
As for whether or not such a device exists in D&D 5e, I'm not sure. I know they explicitly existed in 3.5e because I've run premade campaigns for 3.5e that had them, but I've never encountered them in 5e before.
Barring the possibility of an actual teleport trap in the official rules, you have two options:
1. If you're playing rules-as-written.
You can create a similar effect by using a Glyph of Warding with Teleport (or another spell that can produce the required teleportation effect) as the stored spell, and a trigger of a creature handling the warded object. This has a couple of specific limitations:
- For most teleport type spells, it's dependent on how the DM interprets 'willing'. Personally, I see three ways this could be interpreted in this circumstance:
- The creature handling the object makes it implicitly willing, independent of whether or not the know about the glyph or want it to go off. In essence, they don't care what happens as a result of them handling the item. If I were to rule like this, it would be with some obvious indication that the item was magical, so that they would at least have the knowledge that they probably should be careful with it, which would actually make it the next case.
- The creature handling the object is willing only if they know about the spell. In other words, they know something will happen if they handle the object, possibly even what, and their decision to handle it anyway is functionally an explicit expression of willingness.
- They are only willing if they know about the spell and want the specific effect to happen. This is likely how most AL DM's will rule, as it's the closest to the established RAI for the Teleport spell.
- Barring the above, you're going to have to use an AoE teleport effect like a Teleportation Circle, which will of course teleport anything within range when the trigger goes off.
- Independent of either of the first two limitations, this is probably going to be a one-shot effect. Glyph of Warding triggers, and then is of course gone because the spell completed. You would need an effect equivalent to the old spell Permanency to make it a repeatable effect.
2. If you're playing with the opportunity of homebrew rules.
If you're the DM, just do it, there's no reason (provided your players know to expect non RAW items and such) to not do so. Just be careful you don't make it feel like you're railroading (as both a DM and a player, I would consider this a borderline case).
If you're a player, talk with the DM and see if you can come up with something together to get the desired effect. Most DM's love creative players.
In either case, consider the possibility of a high DC Wisdom or Charisma save to resist the Teleport effect. This can help players feel like they have some chance of not getting caught by it, and can also lead to some really fun gameplay if you're using an AoE teleport.
"Willing" may be up to DM interpretation to the extent that anything in the game is up to DM interpretation - but by default, it means what the word means in everyday language. #1 (under the RAW section) definitely doesn't meet that definition, and I'd say neither does #2 (though that one might be slightly more up for debate).
– V2Blast
Nov 24 at 21:54
3
To my knowledge, permanency is not a spell in 5e (that players can access). Proof
– BBeast
Nov 24 at 23:38
1
There's another case of willing where the player has no clue about the spell but still intends the direct effect of it, e.g. if the item-trigger is turning a doorknob, and the effect is that you teleport into the room on the other side of the door (but the door never opens and actually you are now locked into the room with a minotuar).... you were willingly trying to enter the room and, you did!
– BigJamey
Nov 25 at 0:24
@BBeast You are correct, and I've edited the answer to reflect this fact. I'm used to playing 3.5e, and I had forgotten that Permanency had gotten axed in later editions.
– Austin Hemmelgarn
Nov 25 at 1:32
@BigJamey Excellent point, but from what the OP said in their question, I don't think it really applies for their purposes.
– Austin Hemmelgarn
Nov 25 at 1:33
|
show 1 more comment
4 Answers
4
active
oldest
votes
4 Answers
4
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
up vote
22
down vote
Short Answer: Yes, you can.
I'm not familiar with the D&D5 rules in particular, but even if there wouldn't be any mention of a teleporting item or spell, nothing prevents you as a GM from making it up for your table or specific campaign.
The same goes for any limitations on existing items. If it doesn't exactly work the way you need by the rules, you can just houserule it to do so.
add a comment |
up vote
22
down vote
Short Answer: Yes, you can.
I'm not familiar with the D&D5 rules in particular, but even if there wouldn't be any mention of a teleporting item or spell, nothing prevents you as a GM from making it up for your table or specific campaign.
The same goes for any limitations on existing items. If it doesn't exactly work the way you need by the rules, you can just houserule it to do so.
add a comment |
up vote
22
down vote
up vote
22
down vote
Short Answer: Yes, you can.
I'm not familiar with the D&D5 rules in particular, but even if there wouldn't be any mention of a teleporting item or spell, nothing prevents you as a GM from making it up for your table or specific campaign.
The same goes for any limitations on existing items. If it doesn't exactly work the way you need by the rules, you can just houserule it to do so.
Short Answer: Yes, you can.
I'm not familiar with the D&D5 rules in particular, but even if there wouldn't be any mention of a teleporting item or spell, nothing prevents you as a GM from making it up for your table or specific campaign.
The same goes for any limitations on existing items. If it doesn't exactly work the way you need by the rules, you can just houserule it to do so.
answered Nov 24 at 12:51
Silverclaw
57629
57629
add a comment |
add a comment |
up vote
8
down vote
Glyph of Warding
Have an NPC wizard cast glyph of warding, along with teleportation circle spell as the stored spell, declaring the top of the tower as your destination. Specify your trigger "when a creature touch this glyph/object".
Of course, PC can also do this.
Note: You can use teleport instead of teleportation circle, but teleportation circle is far superior.
teleport requires the triggering creature to be "willing". Your DM may rule that the triggering creature is not willing, thus wasting your spell.
teleport can only target the triggering creature, because the glyph of warding requires the stored spell to target a single creature or an area.
teleport is a 7th level spell, while teleportation circle is a 5th level one. You have access to teleportation circle earlier, and will only need 5th level spell slot instead of 7th.
teleport has a chance to fail, even when teleporting to a permanent magic circle. If you need a reliable method, teleportation circle is better.
Some also argues that teleportation circle is not a valid spell for glyph of warding, you can learn more about that from this question: Glyph of Warding and Teleportation Circle
2
-1, because teleportation circle doesn't just snatch people up. It creates a portal the person has to walk through: "A shimmering portal opens within the circle you drew and remains open until the end of your next turn. Any creature that enters the portal instantly appears within 5 feet of the destination circle or in the nearest unoccupied space if that space is occupied."
– T.J.L.
Nov 26 at 13:47
add a comment |
up vote
8
down vote
Glyph of Warding
Have an NPC wizard cast glyph of warding, along with teleportation circle spell as the stored spell, declaring the top of the tower as your destination. Specify your trigger "when a creature touch this glyph/object".
Of course, PC can also do this.
Note: You can use teleport instead of teleportation circle, but teleportation circle is far superior.
teleport requires the triggering creature to be "willing". Your DM may rule that the triggering creature is not willing, thus wasting your spell.
teleport can only target the triggering creature, because the glyph of warding requires the stored spell to target a single creature or an area.
teleport is a 7th level spell, while teleportation circle is a 5th level one. You have access to teleportation circle earlier, and will only need 5th level spell slot instead of 7th.
teleport has a chance to fail, even when teleporting to a permanent magic circle. If you need a reliable method, teleportation circle is better.
Some also argues that teleportation circle is not a valid spell for glyph of warding, you can learn more about that from this question: Glyph of Warding and Teleportation Circle
2
-1, because teleportation circle doesn't just snatch people up. It creates a portal the person has to walk through: "A shimmering portal opens within the circle you drew and remains open until the end of your next turn. Any creature that enters the portal instantly appears within 5 feet of the destination circle or in the nearest unoccupied space if that space is occupied."
– T.J.L.
Nov 26 at 13:47
add a comment |
up vote
8
down vote
up vote
8
down vote
Glyph of Warding
Have an NPC wizard cast glyph of warding, along with teleportation circle spell as the stored spell, declaring the top of the tower as your destination. Specify your trigger "when a creature touch this glyph/object".
Of course, PC can also do this.
Note: You can use teleport instead of teleportation circle, but teleportation circle is far superior.
teleport requires the triggering creature to be "willing". Your DM may rule that the triggering creature is not willing, thus wasting your spell.
teleport can only target the triggering creature, because the glyph of warding requires the stored spell to target a single creature or an area.
teleport is a 7th level spell, while teleportation circle is a 5th level one. You have access to teleportation circle earlier, and will only need 5th level spell slot instead of 7th.
teleport has a chance to fail, even when teleporting to a permanent magic circle. If you need a reliable method, teleportation circle is better.
Some also argues that teleportation circle is not a valid spell for glyph of warding, you can learn more about that from this question: Glyph of Warding and Teleportation Circle
Glyph of Warding
Have an NPC wizard cast glyph of warding, along with teleportation circle spell as the stored spell, declaring the top of the tower as your destination. Specify your trigger "when a creature touch this glyph/object".
Of course, PC can also do this.
Note: You can use teleport instead of teleportation circle, but teleportation circle is far superior.
teleport requires the triggering creature to be "willing". Your DM may rule that the triggering creature is not willing, thus wasting your spell.
teleport can only target the triggering creature, because the glyph of warding requires the stored spell to target a single creature or an area.
teleport is a 7th level spell, while teleportation circle is a 5th level one. You have access to teleportation circle earlier, and will only need 5th level spell slot instead of 7th.
teleport has a chance to fail, even when teleporting to a permanent magic circle. If you need a reliable method, teleportation circle is better.
Some also argues that teleportation circle is not a valid spell for glyph of warding, you can learn more about that from this question: Glyph of Warding and Teleportation Circle
edited Nov 26 at 13:16
answered Nov 24 at 14:12
Vylix
8,817233112
8,817233112
2
-1, because teleportation circle doesn't just snatch people up. It creates a portal the person has to walk through: "A shimmering portal opens within the circle you drew and remains open until the end of your next turn. Any creature that enters the portal instantly appears within 5 feet of the destination circle or in the nearest unoccupied space if that space is occupied."
– T.J.L.
Nov 26 at 13:47
add a comment |
2
-1, because teleportation circle doesn't just snatch people up. It creates a portal the person has to walk through: "A shimmering portal opens within the circle you drew and remains open until the end of your next turn. Any creature that enters the portal instantly appears within 5 feet of the destination circle or in the nearest unoccupied space if that space is occupied."
– T.J.L.
Nov 26 at 13:47
2
2
-1, because teleportation circle doesn't just snatch people up. It creates a portal the person has to walk through: "A shimmering portal opens within the circle you drew and remains open until the end of your next turn. Any creature that enters the portal instantly appears within 5 feet of the destination circle or in the nearest unoccupied space if that space is occupied."
– T.J.L.
Nov 26 at 13:47
-1, because teleportation circle doesn't just snatch people up. It creates a portal the person has to walk through: "A shimmering portal opens within the circle you drew and remains open until the end of your next turn. Any creature that enters the portal instantly appears within 5 feet of the destination circle or in the nearest unoccupied space if that space is occupied."
– T.J.L.
Nov 26 at 13:47
add a comment |
up vote
4
down vote
Yes, you can absolutely do this
As others have mentioned there is significant GM Fiat to create such creations in D&D 5e.
Note: the rest of this answer contains spoilers for a portion of a published adventure.
You might want to take some inspiration from the adventure
Waterdeep: Dungeon of the Mad Mage.
In that adventure:
On level 15 (p. 194), the concept of a Teleport Trap is introduced that has the following effect:
A creature that enters the trap’s space is teleported along with any objects it is wearing or carrying to another teleport trap (or the nearest unoccupied space). There is no saving throw to resist the teleportation effect, and the destination varies from trap to trap. Once a creature has been teleported in this way, it is unaffected by teleport traps on this level for 1 hour.
When a creature is teleported by a trap, Halaster’s booming voice shouts “Teleported!” in Common. The magical voice originates at the point of departure and the point of arrival, and it is audible in both locations out to a range of 100 feet.
Some teleport traps have additional effects, as described in their encounter locations.
There is some additional information in the adventure, including
details on placement of the traps and some important DCs for PCs finding them.
It also has this highlighted note on the intended effect of the teleportation traps:
Splitting the Party. Teleport traps are designed to split the party [...]
The idea of a voice-over taunt/quote when a trap is triggered sounds hilarious.
– V2Blast
Nov 25 at 18:58
@V2Blast I like the idea of it alright...will be a while before I get to spring it one my players though
– illustro
Nov 26 at 10:07
add a comment |
up vote
4
down vote
Yes, you can absolutely do this
As others have mentioned there is significant GM Fiat to create such creations in D&D 5e.
Note: the rest of this answer contains spoilers for a portion of a published adventure.
You might want to take some inspiration from the adventure
Waterdeep: Dungeon of the Mad Mage.
In that adventure:
On level 15 (p. 194), the concept of a Teleport Trap is introduced that has the following effect:
A creature that enters the trap’s space is teleported along with any objects it is wearing or carrying to another teleport trap (or the nearest unoccupied space). There is no saving throw to resist the teleportation effect, and the destination varies from trap to trap. Once a creature has been teleported in this way, it is unaffected by teleport traps on this level for 1 hour.
When a creature is teleported by a trap, Halaster’s booming voice shouts “Teleported!” in Common. The magical voice originates at the point of departure and the point of arrival, and it is audible in both locations out to a range of 100 feet.
Some teleport traps have additional effects, as described in their encounter locations.
There is some additional information in the adventure, including
details on placement of the traps and some important DCs for PCs finding them.
It also has this highlighted note on the intended effect of the teleportation traps:
Splitting the Party. Teleport traps are designed to split the party [...]
The idea of a voice-over taunt/quote when a trap is triggered sounds hilarious.
– V2Blast
Nov 25 at 18:58
@V2Blast I like the idea of it alright...will be a while before I get to spring it one my players though
– illustro
Nov 26 at 10:07
add a comment |
up vote
4
down vote
up vote
4
down vote
Yes, you can absolutely do this
As others have mentioned there is significant GM Fiat to create such creations in D&D 5e.
Note: the rest of this answer contains spoilers for a portion of a published adventure.
You might want to take some inspiration from the adventure
Waterdeep: Dungeon of the Mad Mage.
In that adventure:
On level 15 (p. 194), the concept of a Teleport Trap is introduced that has the following effect:
A creature that enters the trap’s space is teleported along with any objects it is wearing or carrying to another teleport trap (or the nearest unoccupied space). There is no saving throw to resist the teleportation effect, and the destination varies from trap to trap. Once a creature has been teleported in this way, it is unaffected by teleport traps on this level for 1 hour.
When a creature is teleported by a trap, Halaster’s booming voice shouts “Teleported!” in Common. The magical voice originates at the point of departure and the point of arrival, and it is audible in both locations out to a range of 100 feet.
Some teleport traps have additional effects, as described in their encounter locations.
There is some additional information in the adventure, including
details on placement of the traps and some important DCs for PCs finding them.
It also has this highlighted note on the intended effect of the teleportation traps:
Splitting the Party. Teleport traps are designed to split the party [...]
Yes, you can absolutely do this
As others have mentioned there is significant GM Fiat to create such creations in D&D 5e.
Note: the rest of this answer contains spoilers for a portion of a published adventure.
You might want to take some inspiration from the adventure
Waterdeep: Dungeon of the Mad Mage.
In that adventure:
On level 15 (p. 194), the concept of a Teleport Trap is introduced that has the following effect:
A creature that enters the trap’s space is teleported along with any objects it is wearing or carrying to another teleport trap (or the nearest unoccupied space). There is no saving throw to resist the teleportation effect, and the destination varies from trap to trap. Once a creature has been teleported in this way, it is unaffected by teleport traps on this level for 1 hour.
When a creature is teleported by a trap, Halaster’s booming voice shouts “Teleported!” in Common. The magical voice originates at the point of departure and the point of arrival, and it is audible in both locations out to a range of 100 feet.
Some teleport traps have additional effects, as described in their encounter locations.
There is some additional information in the adventure, including
details on placement of the traps and some important DCs for PCs finding them.
It also has this highlighted note on the intended effect of the teleportation traps:
Splitting the Party. Teleport traps are designed to split the party [...]
edited Nov 26 at 10:52
answered Nov 25 at 17:41
illustro
5,22021245
5,22021245
The idea of a voice-over taunt/quote when a trap is triggered sounds hilarious.
– V2Blast
Nov 25 at 18:58
@V2Blast I like the idea of it alright...will be a while before I get to spring it one my players though
– illustro
Nov 26 at 10:07
add a comment |
The idea of a voice-over taunt/quote when a trap is triggered sounds hilarious.
– V2Blast
Nov 25 at 18:58
@V2Blast I like the idea of it alright...will be a while before I get to spring it one my players though
– illustro
Nov 26 at 10:07
The idea of a voice-over taunt/quote when a trap is triggered sounds hilarious.
– V2Blast
Nov 25 at 18:58
The idea of a voice-over taunt/quote when a trap is triggered sounds hilarious.
– V2Blast
Nov 25 at 18:58
@V2Blast I like the idea of it alright...will be a while before I get to spring it one my players though
– illustro
Nov 26 at 10:07
@V2Blast I like the idea of it alright...will be a while before I get to spring it one my players though
– illustro
Nov 26 at 10:07
add a comment |
up vote
2
down vote
In a lot of D&D-like systems, there's the concept of a 'teleport trap', which is almost exactly what you're asking for. The first example that comes to my mind is the teleport traps in Nethack, which will send you randomly to a different location on the same floor, or possibly to a different floor for specific types, when you step on a specific square.
As for whether or not such a device exists in D&D 5e, I'm not sure. I know they explicitly existed in 3.5e because I've run premade campaigns for 3.5e that had them, but I've never encountered them in 5e before.
Barring the possibility of an actual teleport trap in the official rules, you have two options:
1. If you're playing rules-as-written.
You can create a similar effect by using a Glyph of Warding with Teleport (or another spell that can produce the required teleportation effect) as the stored spell, and a trigger of a creature handling the warded object. This has a couple of specific limitations:
- For most teleport type spells, it's dependent on how the DM interprets 'willing'. Personally, I see three ways this could be interpreted in this circumstance:
- The creature handling the object makes it implicitly willing, independent of whether or not the know about the glyph or want it to go off. In essence, they don't care what happens as a result of them handling the item. If I were to rule like this, it would be with some obvious indication that the item was magical, so that they would at least have the knowledge that they probably should be careful with it, which would actually make it the next case.
- The creature handling the object is willing only if they know about the spell. In other words, they know something will happen if they handle the object, possibly even what, and their decision to handle it anyway is functionally an explicit expression of willingness.
- They are only willing if they know about the spell and want the specific effect to happen. This is likely how most AL DM's will rule, as it's the closest to the established RAI for the Teleport spell.
- Barring the above, you're going to have to use an AoE teleport effect like a Teleportation Circle, which will of course teleport anything within range when the trigger goes off.
- Independent of either of the first two limitations, this is probably going to be a one-shot effect. Glyph of Warding triggers, and then is of course gone because the spell completed. You would need an effect equivalent to the old spell Permanency to make it a repeatable effect.
2. If you're playing with the opportunity of homebrew rules.
If you're the DM, just do it, there's no reason (provided your players know to expect non RAW items and such) to not do so. Just be careful you don't make it feel like you're railroading (as both a DM and a player, I would consider this a borderline case).
If you're a player, talk with the DM and see if you can come up with something together to get the desired effect. Most DM's love creative players.
In either case, consider the possibility of a high DC Wisdom or Charisma save to resist the Teleport effect. This can help players feel like they have some chance of not getting caught by it, and can also lead to some really fun gameplay if you're using an AoE teleport.
"Willing" may be up to DM interpretation to the extent that anything in the game is up to DM interpretation - but by default, it means what the word means in everyday language. #1 (under the RAW section) definitely doesn't meet that definition, and I'd say neither does #2 (though that one might be slightly more up for debate).
– V2Blast
Nov 24 at 21:54
3
To my knowledge, permanency is not a spell in 5e (that players can access). Proof
– BBeast
Nov 24 at 23:38
1
There's another case of willing where the player has no clue about the spell but still intends the direct effect of it, e.g. if the item-trigger is turning a doorknob, and the effect is that you teleport into the room on the other side of the door (but the door never opens and actually you are now locked into the room with a minotuar).... you were willingly trying to enter the room and, you did!
– BigJamey
Nov 25 at 0:24
@BBeast You are correct, and I've edited the answer to reflect this fact. I'm used to playing 3.5e, and I had forgotten that Permanency had gotten axed in later editions.
– Austin Hemmelgarn
Nov 25 at 1:32
@BigJamey Excellent point, but from what the OP said in their question, I don't think it really applies for their purposes.
– Austin Hemmelgarn
Nov 25 at 1:33
|
show 1 more comment
up vote
2
down vote
In a lot of D&D-like systems, there's the concept of a 'teleport trap', which is almost exactly what you're asking for. The first example that comes to my mind is the teleport traps in Nethack, which will send you randomly to a different location on the same floor, or possibly to a different floor for specific types, when you step on a specific square.
As for whether or not such a device exists in D&D 5e, I'm not sure. I know they explicitly existed in 3.5e because I've run premade campaigns for 3.5e that had them, but I've never encountered them in 5e before.
Barring the possibility of an actual teleport trap in the official rules, you have two options:
1. If you're playing rules-as-written.
You can create a similar effect by using a Glyph of Warding with Teleport (or another spell that can produce the required teleportation effect) as the stored spell, and a trigger of a creature handling the warded object. This has a couple of specific limitations:
- For most teleport type spells, it's dependent on how the DM interprets 'willing'. Personally, I see three ways this could be interpreted in this circumstance:
- The creature handling the object makes it implicitly willing, independent of whether or not the know about the glyph or want it to go off. In essence, they don't care what happens as a result of them handling the item. If I were to rule like this, it would be with some obvious indication that the item was magical, so that they would at least have the knowledge that they probably should be careful with it, which would actually make it the next case.
- The creature handling the object is willing only if they know about the spell. In other words, they know something will happen if they handle the object, possibly even what, and their decision to handle it anyway is functionally an explicit expression of willingness.
- They are only willing if they know about the spell and want the specific effect to happen. This is likely how most AL DM's will rule, as it's the closest to the established RAI for the Teleport spell.
- Barring the above, you're going to have to use an AoE teleport effect like a Teleportation Circle, which will of course teleport anything within range when the trigger goes off.
- Independent of either of the first two limitations, this is probably going to be a one-shot effect. Glyph of Warding triggers, and then is of course gone because the spell completed. You would need an effect equivalent to the old spell Permanency to make it a repeatable effect.
2. If you're playing with the opportunity of homebrew rules.
If you're the DM, just do it, there's no reason (provided your players know to expect non RAW items and such) to not do so. Just be careful you don't make it feel like you're railroading (as both a DM and a player, I would consider this a borderline case).
If you're a player, talk with the DM and see if you can come up with something together to get the desired effect. Most DM's love creative players.
In either case, consider the possibility of a high DC Wisdom or Charisma save to resist the Teleport effect. This can help players feel like they have some chance of not getting caught by it, and can also lead to some really fun gameplay if you're using an AoE teleport.
"Willing" may be up to DM interpretation to the extent that anything in the game is up to DM interpretation - but by default, it means what the word means in everyday language. #1 (under the RAW section) definitely doesn't meet that definition, and I'd say neither does #2 (though that one might be slightly more up for debate).
– V2Blast
Nov 24 at 21:54
3
To my knowledge, permanency is not a spell in 5e (that players can access). Proof
– BBeast
Nov 24 at 23:38
1
There's another case of willing where the player has no clue about the spell but still intends the direct effect of it, e.g. if the item-trigger is turning a doorknob, and the effect is that you teleport into the room on the other side of the door (but the door never opens and actually you are now locked into the room with a minotuar).... you were willingly trying to enter the room and, you did!
– BigJamey
Nov 25 at 0:24
@BBeast You are correct, and I've edited the answer to reflect this fact. I'm used to playing 3.5e, and I had forgotten that Permanency had gotten axed in later editions.
– Austin Hemmelgarn
Nov 25 at 1:32
@BigJamey Excellent point, but from what the OP said in their question, I don't think it really applies for their purposes.
– Austin Hemmelgarn
Nov 25 at 1:33
|
show 1 more comment
up vote
2
down vote
up vote
2
down vote
In a lot of D&D-like systems, there's the concept of a 'teleport trap', which is almost exactly what you're asking for. The first example that comes to my mind is the teleport traps in Nethack, which will send you randomly to a different location on the same floor, or possibly to a different floor for specific types, when you step on a specific square.
As for whether or not such a device exists in D&D 5e, I'm not sure. I know they explicitly existed in 3.5e because I've run premade campaigns for 3.5e that had them, but I've never encountered them in 5e before.
Barring the possibility of an actual teleport trap in the official rules, you have two options:
1. If you're playing rules-as-written.
You can create a similar effect by using a Glyph of Warding with Teleport (or another spell that can produce the required teleportation effect) as the stored spell, and a trigger of a creature handling the warded object. This has a couple of specific limitations:
- For most teleport type spells, it's dependent on how the DM interprets 'willing'. Personally, I see three ways this could be interpreted in this circumstance:
- The creature handling the object makes it implicitly willing, independent of whether or not the know about the glyph or want it to go off. In essence, they don't care what happens as a result of them handling the item. If I were to rule like this, it would be with some obvious indication that the item was magical, so that they would at least have the knowledge that they probably should be careful with it, which would actually make it the next case.
- The creature handling the object is willing only if they know about the spell. In other words, they know something will happen if they handle the object, possibly even what, and their decision to handle it anyway is functionally an explicit expression of willingness.
- They are only willing if they know about the spell and want the specific effect to happen. This is likely how most AL DM's will rule, as it's the closest to the established RAI for the Teleport spell.
- Barring the above, you're going to have to use an AoE teleport effect like a Teleportation Circle, which will of course teleport anything within range when the trigger goes off.
- Independent of either of the first two limitations, this is probably going to be a one-shot effect. Glyph of Warding triggers, and then is of course gone because the spell completed. You would need an effect equivalent to the old spell Permanency to make it a repeatable effect.
2. If you're playing with the opportunity of homebrew rules.
If you're the DM, just do it, there's no reason (provided your players know to expect non RAW items and such) to not do so. Just be careful you don't make it feel like you're railroading (as both a DM and a player, I would consider this a borderline case).
If you're a player, talk with the DM and see if you can come up with something together to get the desired effect. Most DM's love creative players.
In either case, consider the possibility of a high DC Wisdom or Charisma save to resist the Teleport effect. This can help players feel like they have some chance of not getting caught by it, and can also lead to some really fun gameplay if you're using an AoE teleport.
In a lot of D&D-like systems, there's the concept of a 'teleport trap', which is almost exactly what you're asking for. The first example that comes to my mind is the teleport traps in Nethack, which will send you randomly to a different location on the same floor, or possibly to a different floor for specific types, when you step on a specific square.
As for whether or not such a device exists in D&D 5e, I'm not sure. I know they explicitly existed in 3.5e because I've run premade campaigns for 3.5e that had them, but I've never encountered them in 5e before.
Barring the possibility of an actual teleport trap in the official rules, you have two options:
1. If you're playing rules-as-written.
You can create a similar effect by using a Glyph of Warding with Teleport (or another spell that can produce the required teleportation effect) as the stored spell, and a trigger of a creature handling the warded object. This has a couple of specific limitations:
- For most teleport type spells, it's dependent on how the DM interprets 'willing'. Personally, I see three ways this could be interpreted in this circumstance:
- The creature handling the object makes it implicitly willing, independent of whether or not the know about the glyph or want it to go off. In essence, they don't care what happens as a result of them handling the item. If I were to rule like this, it would be with some obvious indication that the item was magical, so that they would at least have the knowledge that they probably should be careful with it, which would actually make it the next case.
- The creature handling the object is willing only if they know about the spell. In other words, they know something will happen if they handle the object, possibly even what, and their decision to handle it anyway is functionally an explicit expression of willingness.
- They are only willing if they know about the spell and want the specific effect to happen. This is likely how most AL DM's will rule, as it's the closest to the established RAI for the Teleport spell.
- Barring the above, you're going to have to use an AoE teleport effect like a Teleportation Circle, which will of course teleport anything within range when the trigger goes off.
- Independent of either of the first two limitations, this is probably going to be a one-shot effect. Glyph of Warding triggers, and then is of course gone because the spell completed. You would need an effect equivalent to the old spell Permanency to make it a repeatable effect.
2. If you're playing with the opportunity of homebrew rules.
If you're the DM, just do it, there's no reason (provided your players know to expect non RAW items and such) to not do so. Just be careful you don't make it feel like you're railroading (as both a DM and a player, I would consider this a borderline case).
If you're a player, talk with the DM and see if you can come up with something together to get the desired effect. Most DM's love creative players.
In either case, consider the possibility of a high DC Wisdom or Charisma save to resist the Teleport effect. This can help players feel like they have some chance of not getting caught by it, and can also lead to some really fun gameplay if you're using an AoE teleport.
edited Nov 25 at 1:31
answered Nov 24 at 21:09
Austin Hemmelgarn
19914
19914
"Willing" may be up to DM interpretation to the extent that anything in the game is up to DM interpretation - but by default, it means what the word means in everyday language. #1 (under the RAW section) definitely doesn't meet that definition, and I'd say neither does #2 (though that one might be slightly more up for debate).
– V2Blast
Nov 24 at 21:54
3
To my knowledge, permanency is not a spell in 5e (that players can access). Proof
– BBeast
Nov 24 at 23:38
1
There's another case of willing where the player has no clue about the spell but still intends the direct effect of it, e.g. if the item-trigger is turning a doorknob, and the effect is that you teleport into the room on the other side of the door (but the door never opens and actually you are now locked into the room with a minotuar).... you were willingly trying to enter the room and, you did!
– BigJamey
Nov 25 at 0:24
@BBeast You are correct, and I've edited the answer to reflect this fact. I'm used to playing 3.5e, and I had forgotten that Permanency had gotten axed in later editions.
– Austin Hemmelgarn
Nov 25 at 1:32
@BigJamey Excellent point, but from what the OP said in their question, I don't think it really applies for their purposes.
– Austin Hemmelgarn
Nov 25 at 1:33
|
show 1 more comment
"Willing" may be up to DM interpretation to the extent that anything in the game is up to DM interpretation - but by default, it means what the word means in everyday language. #1 (under the RAW section) definitely doesn't meet that definition, and I'd say neither does #2 (though that one might be slightly more up for debate).
– V2Blast
Nov 24 at 21:54
3
To my knowledge, permanency is not a spell in 5e (that players can access). Proof
– BBeast
Nov 24 at 23:38
1
There's another case of willing where the player has no clue about the spell but still intends the direct effect of it, e.g. if the item-trigger is turning a doorknob, and the effect is that you teleport into the room on the other side of the door (but the door never opens and actually you are now locked into the room with a minotuar).... you were willingly trying to enter the room and, you did!
– BigJamey
Nov 25 at 0:24
@BBeast You are correct, and I've edited the answer to reflect this fact. I'm used to playing 3.5e, and I had forgotten that Permanency had gotten axed in later editions.
– Austin Hemmelgarn
Nov 25 at 1:32
@BigJamey Excellent point, but from what the OP said in their question, I don't think it really applies for their purposes.
– Austin Hemmelgarn
Nov 25 at 1:33
"Willing" may be up to DM interpretation to the extent that anything in the game is up to DM interpretation - but by default, it means what the word means in everyday language. #1 (under the RAW section) definitely doesn't meet that definition, and I'd say neither does #2 (though that one might be slightly more up for debate).
– V2Blast
Nov 24 at 21:54
"Willing" may be up to DM interpretation to the extent that anything in the game is up to DM interpretation - but by default, it means what the word means in everyday language. #1 (under the RAW section) definitely doesn't meet that definition, and I'd say neither does #2 (though that one might be slightly more up for debate).
– V2Blast
Nov 24 at 21:54
3
3
To my knowledge, permanency is not a spell in 5e (that players can access). Proof
– BBeast
Nov 24 at 23:38
To my knowledge, permanency is not a spell in 5e (that players can access). Proof
– BBeast
Nov 24 at 23:38
1
1
There's another case of willing where the player has no clue about the spell but still intends the direct effect of it, e.g. if the item-trigger is turning a doorknob, and the effect is that you teleport into the room on the other side of the door (but the door never opens and actually you are now locked into the room with a minotuar).... you were willingly trying to enter the room and, you did!
– BigJamey
Nov 25 at 0:24
There's another case of willing where the player has no clue about the spell but still intends the direct effect of it, e.g. if the item-trigger is turning a doorknob, and the effect is that you teleport into the room on the other side of the door (but the door never opens and actually you are now locked into the room with a minotuar).... you were willingly trying to enter the room and, you did!
– BigJamey
Nov 25 at 0:24
@BBeast You are correct, and I've edited the answer to reflect this fact. I'm used to playing 3.5e, and I had forgotten that Permanency had gotten axed in later editions.
– Austin Hemmelgarn
Nov 25 at 1:32
@BBeast You are correct, and I've edited the answer to reflect this fact. I'm used to playing 3.5e, and I had forgotten that Permanency had gotten axed in later editions.
– Austin Hemmelgarn
Nov 25 at 1:32
@BigJamey Excellent point, but from what the OP said in their question, I don't think it really applies for their purposes.
– Austin Hemmelgarn
Nov 25 at 1:33
@BigJamey Excellent point, but from what the OP said in their question, I don't think it really applies for their purposes.
– Austin Hemmelgarn
Nov 25 at 1:33
|
show 1 more comment
George is a new contributor. Be nice, and check out our Code of Conduct.
George is a new contributor. Be nice, and check out our Code of Conduct.
George is a new contributor. Be nice, and check out our Code of Conduct.
George is a new contributor. Be nice, and check out our Code of Conduct.
Thanks for contributing an answer to Role-playing Games Stack Exchange!
- Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!
But avoid …
- Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.
- Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.
Use MathJax to format equations. MathJax reference.
To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.
Some of your past answers have not been well-received, and you're in danger of being blocked from answering.
Please pay close attention to the following guidance:
- Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!
But avoid …
- Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.
- Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.
To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function () {
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2frpg.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f136145%2fcan-i-make-an-object-so-that-when-the-characters-touch-it-they-are-teleported-s%23new-answer', 'question_page');
}
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
2
@enkryptor Editing the question like that would assume that the answer is already “you can only do this with spell X” — which defeats the purpose of asking, and suggesting such an edit assumes that is the answer, when it is not necessarily. So no, it’s not necessary to edit the question to specify that it works like spell X.
– SevenSidedDie♦
Nov 24 at 17:11