Why cycle the magnetos before engine shutdown?











up vote
16
down vote

favorite
2












Inspired by this question asking about shutting down a light aircraft engine I realised there is another ritual which I do, but have long forgotten the reason why.



Having parked a light aircraft, and switched off the electrics, with the engine still running I always check left and right magnetos, similar to the magneto drop check done as pre-flight checks.



I don't really pay much attention to the RPM, I do it because I've always done it. It's not (as far as I remember) on my shutdown checklist - and I'm starting to wonder why I do it.



Is this necessary? Something in the back of my mind is saying "prevents mag fouling". What is the real reason to cycle Left & Right mag pre-shutdown?










share|improve this question


















  • 1




    Pay attention to the drop and look for roughness. If you didn’t lean enough on your flight, you may have fouled the plugs. It’s better to know that when you shut down rather than when you get to the runup area for your next flight.
    – JScarry
    Nov 20 at 16:42










  • So called mag fouling normally refers to spark plug fouling, and that is normally addressed during run-up by leaning the mixture to a hot and lean mixture, at a reduced power setting (like 1900 or 2000 RPM) and running with both mags selected for several minutes. Then the mag drops are retested.
    – mongo
    Nov 20 at 18:41















up vote
16
down vote

favorite
2












Inspired by this question asking about shutting down a light aircraft engine I realised there is another ritual which I do, but have long forgotten the reason why.



Having parked a light aircraft, and switched off the electrics, with the engine still running I always check left and right magnetos, similar to the magneto drop check done as pre-flight checks.



I don't really pay much attention to the RPM, I do it because I've always done it. It's not (as far as I remember) on my shutdown checklist - and I'm starting to wonder why I do it.



Is this necessary? Something in the back of my mind is saying "prevents mag fouling". What is the real reason to cycle Left & Right mag pre-shutdown?










share|improve this question


















  • 1




    Pay attention to the drop and look for roughness. If you didn’t lean enough on your flight, you may have fouled the plugs. It’s better to know that when you shut down rather than when you get to the runup area for your next flight.
    – JScarry
    Nov 20 at 16:42










  • So called mag fouling normally refers to spark plug fouling, and that is normally addressed during run-up by leaning the mixture to a hot and lean mixture, at a reduced power setting (like 1900 or 2000 RPM) and running with both mags selected for several minutes. Then the mag drops are retested.
    – mongo
    Nov 20 at 18:41













up vote
16
down vote

favorite
2









up vote
16
down vote

favorite
2






2





Inspired by this question asking about shutting down a light aircraft engine I realised there is another ritual which I do, but have long forgotten the reason why.



Having parked a light aircraft, and switched off the electrics, with the engine still running I always check left and right magnetos, similar to the magneto drop check done as pre-flight checks.



I don't really pay much attention to the RPM, I do it because I've always done it. It's not (as far as I remember) on my shutdown checklist - and I'm starting to wonder why I do it.



Is this necessary? Something in the back of my mind is saying "prevents mag fouling". What is the real reason to cycle Left & Right mag pre-shutdown?










share|improve this question













Inspired by this question asking about shutting down a light aircraft engine I realised there is another ritual which I do, but have long forgotten the reason why.



Having parked a light aircraft, and switched off the electrics, with the engine still running I always check left and right magnetos, similar to the magneto drop check done as pre-flight checks.



I don't really pay much attention to the RPM, I do it because I've always done it. It's not (as far as I remember) on my shutdown checklist - and I'm starting to wonder why I do it.



Is this necessary? Something in the back of my mind is saying "prevents mag fouling". What is the real reason to cycle Left & Right mag pre-shutdown?







piston-engine






share|improve this question













share|improve this question











share|improve this question




share|improve this question










asked Nov 20 at 12:34









Jamiec

14.4k35787




14.4k35787








  • 1




    Pay attention to the drop and look for roughness. If you didn’t lean enough on your flight, you may have fouled the plugs. It’s better to know that when you shut down rather than when you get to the runup area for your next flight.
    – JScarry
    Nov 20 at 16:42










  • So called mag fouling normally refers to spark plug fouling, and that is normally addressed during run-up by leaning the mixture to a hot and lean mixture, at a reduced power setting (like 1900 or 2000 RPM) and running with both mags selected for several minutes. Then the mag drops are retested.
    – mongo
    Nov 20 at 18:41














  • 1




    Pay attention to the drop and look for roughness. If you didn’t lean enough on your flight, you may have fouled the plugs. It’s better to know that when you shut down rather than when you get to the runup area for your next flight.
    – JScarry
    Nov 20 at 16:42










  • So called mag fouling normally refers to spark plug fouling, and that is normally addressed during run-up by leaning the mixture to a hot and lean mixture, at a reduced power setting (like 1900 or 2000 RPM) and running with both mags selected for several minutes. Then the mag drops are retested.
    – mongo
    Nov 20 at 18:41








1




1




Pay attention to the drop and look for roughness. If you didn’t lean enough on your flight, you may have fouled the plugs. It’s better to know that when you shut down rather than when you get to the runup area for your next flight.
– JScarry
Nov 20 at 16:42




Pay attention to the drop and look for roughness. If you didn’t lean enough on your flight, you may have fouled the plugs. It’s better to know that when you shut down rather than when you get to the runup area for your next flight.
– JScarry
Nov 20 at 16:42












So called mag fouling normally refers to spark plug fouling, and that is normally addressed during run-up by leaning the mixture to a hot and lean mixture, at a reduced power setting (like 1900 or 2000 RPM) and running with both mags selected for several minutes. Then the mag drops are retested.
– mongo
Nov 20 at 18:41




So called mag fouling normally refers to spark plug fouling, and that is normally addressed during run-up by leaning the mixture to a hot and lean mixture, at a reduced power setting (like 1900 or 2000 RPM) and running with both mags selected for several minutes. Then the mag drops are retested.
– mongo
Nov 20 at 18:41










3 Answers
3






active

oldest

votes

















up vote
22
down vote



accepted










This is a hot-mag check to verify that when you shut the engine down, you are really putting it in a safe(r) state. Think about how the mag-switch works, when you switch to R or L, it grounds the P-Lead on the other side (so switching to R grounds the P-Lead on the Left side). If you don't see the RPM drop, you may have a hot mag on that side.



An un-grounded mag is a dangerous situation in that it can cause the aircraft engine to turn over if you accidentally (or intentionally) move the prop when you are parking the aircraft, or when somebody walks by and runs into your prop.



So during this mag check you are only looking for an RPM drop or a change that tells you that the mag is shut off.






share|improve this answer

















  • 1




    That’s what I was taught, but really, isn’t testing each mag for a drop doing the same thing? It won’t drop if there’s a ground. I guess that wouldn’t verify no ground in the switch itself when set to OFF.
    – Greg Taylor
    Nov 20 at 16:29






  • 4




    Yes, the reason you do it at shutdown though is that you've just finished flying the aircraft and you are about to move it (possibly push it by placing your hands on the prop). You want to be sure that if you accidentally move the prop it doesn't kick over. You want to make sure that a P-Lead didn't disconnect in flight, the run-up is for checking mag quality and plug fouling, the shutdown is for checking p-lead.
    – Ron Beyer
    Nov 20 at 16:36


















up vote
10
down vote













You are doing it wrong if you are just cycling left/right/both. It is a hot mag check, not a mag function check like on a runup. You are supposed to cycle them to OFF and then back on to BOTH before shutdown and listen for the sound of combustion stopping in the exhaust. You do it after the engine has had time to cool down and while the engine is at idle to avoid backfires.



Remember that magnetos are disabled (shut off) by grounding out the primary circuit. If the P lead, the ground out wire, to the ignition switch breaks, the mag is prevented from turning off and remains live. You are making sure they are grounding out and really shutting off so you don't have an undetetected live mag after shutdown. You have to do this because shutdown is done with the mixture cutoff and if the one mag is live after being turned off you won't know it, and a surprise could occur if the prop is moved later and the mag fires with residual fuel mixture in the cylinders.






share|improve this answer

















  • 2




    I don't think you adequately explain why it is wrong to cycle left/right/both. My understanding is that if there's a mag drop on left, and another one on right then it proves both mags are grounding properly as well as turning the key to off. Turning it to off means you get fuel in the exhaust system.
    – GdD
    Nov 20 at 16:28










  • To get a noticeable mag drop you have to have some power on. This check is done just before shutting down, when at idle. Yes a bit of unburned fuel gets through, but when done at idle after the engine's cooled down it's not sufficient to cause a back fire and when you put the mags back on you're back to normal. You only have them switched off for a quarter to half a second. I've been doing it for 40+ years and have never had a backfire.
    – John K
    Nov 20 at 17:54


















up vote
4
down vote













This is going to give the same reason as Ron Beyer's answer. I'm only writing another because I found his a little hard to follow and I'm going to try to explain it differently. It's nothing to do with mag fouling at all.





The magnetos are wired up so that a failure of the switch or wiring leaves them live (on), unlike most electrical devices which are wired to be off if they fail. This is normally what you want because if the wiring fails in-flight, you'd like the magnetos to keep working. But it can cause a dangerous state, where the magnetos are stuck on when you think they're off. If you swung the prop in that condition, it could fire when you're not expecting it.



So one at a time, we switch a magneto off, and check that the RPM appears to drop, and that the engine sound changes. The sound is more important - as John K says, the drop is small at the kind of RPM you do your mag drop test, and hard to see unambiguously on the gauge. This way, you know that switching it off really does isolate the magneto, so you know that when you turn both off after stopping the engine, the propeller is safe.



It's not so much for your benefit as whoever will touch or fly the aircraft next. Even so, you should always treat a propeller as live. If you have to swing it (e.g. to inspect it), do so as if you were hand-cranking the engine, keeping well clear and making sure your arm comes out of its path.






share|improve this answer





















    Your Answer





    StackExchange.ifUsing("editor", function () {
    return StackExchange.using("mathjaxEditing", function () {
    StackExchange.MarkdownEditor.creationCallbacks.add(function (editor, postfix) {
    StackExchange.mathjaxEditing.prepareWmdForMathJax(editor, postfix, [["$", "$"], ["\\(","\\)"]]);
    });
    });
    }, "mathjax-editing");

    StackExchange.ready(function() {
    var channelOptions = {
    tags: "".split(" "),
    id: "528"
    };
    initTagRenderer("".split(" "), "".split(" "), channelOptions);

    StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function() {
    // Have to fire editor after snippets, if snippets enabled
    if (StackExchange.settings.snippets.snippetsEnabled) {
    StackExchange.using("snippets", function() {
    createEditor();
    });
    }
    else {
    createEditor();
    }
    });

    function createEditor() {
    StackExchange.prepareEditor({
    heartbeatType: 'answer',
    convertImagesToLinks: false,
    noModals: true,
    showLowRepImageUploadWarning: true,
    reputationToPostImages: null,
    bindNavPrevention: true,
    postfix: "",
    imageUploader: {
    brandingHtml: "Powered by u003ca class="icon-imgur-white" href="https://imgur.com/"u003eu003c/au003e",
    contentPolicyHtml: "User contributions licensed under u003ca href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/"u003ecc by-sa 3.0 with attribution requiredu003c/au003e u003ca href="https://stackoverflow.com/legal/content-policy"u003e(content policy)u003c/au003e",
    allowUrls: true
    },
    noCode: true, onDemand: true,
    discardSelector: ".discard-answer"
    ,immediatelyShowMarkdownHelp:true
    });


    }
    });














    draft saved

    draft discarded


















    StackExchange.ready(
    function () {
    StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2faviation.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f57290%2fwhy-cycle-the-magnetos-before-engine-shutdown%23new-answer', 'question_page');
    }
    );

    Post as a guest















    Required, but never shown

























    3 Answers
    3






    active

    oldest

    votes








    3 Answers
    3






    active

    oldest

    votes









    active

    oldest

    votes






    active

    oldest

    votes








    up vote
    22
    down vote



    accepted










    This is a hot-mag check to verify that when you shut the engine down, you are really putting it in a safe(r) state. Think about how the mag-switch works, when you switch to R or L, it grounds the P-Lead on the other side (so switching to R grounds the P-Lead on the Left side). If you don't see the RPM drop, you may have a hot mag on that side.



    An un-grounded mag is a dangerous situation in that it can cause the aircraft engine to turn over if you accidentally (or intentionally) move the prop when you are parking the aircraft, or when somebody walks by and runs into your prop.



    So during this mag check you are only looking for an RPM drop or a change that tells you that the mag is shut off.






    share|improve this answer

















    • 1




      That’s what I was taught, but really, isn’t testing each mag for a drop doing the same thing? It won’t drop if there’s a ground. I guess that wouldn’t verify no ground in the switch itself when set to OFF.
      – Greg Taylor
      Nov 20 at 16:29






    • 4




      Yes, the reason you do it at shutdown though is that you've just finished flying the aircraft and you are about to move it (possibly push it by placing your hands on the prop). You want to be sure that if you accidentally move the prop it doesn't kick over. You want to make sure that a P-Lead didn't disconnect in flight, the run-up is for checking mag quality and plug fouling, the shutdown is for checking p-lead.
      – Ron Beyer
      Nov 20 at 16:36















    up vote
    22
    down vote



    accepted










    This is a hot-mag check to verify that when you shut the engine down, you are really putting it in a safe(r) state. Think about how the mag-switch works, when you switch to R or L, it grounds the P-Lead on the other side (so switching to R grounds the P-Lead on the Left side). If you don't see the RPM drop, you may have a hot mag on that side.



    An un-grounded mag is a dangerous situation in that it can cause the aircraft engine to turn over if you accidentally (or intentionally) move the prop when you are parking the aircraft, or when somebody walks by and runs into your prop.



    So during this mag check you are only looking for an RPM drop or a change that tells you that the mag is shut off.






    share|improve this answer

















    • 1




      That’s what I was taught, but really, isn’t testing each mag for a drop doing the same thing? It won’t drop if there’s a ground. I guess that wouldn’t verify no ground in the switch itself when set to OFF.
      – Greg Taylor
      Nov 20 at 16:29






    • 4




      Yes, the reason you do it at shutdown though is that you've just finished flying the aircraft and you are about to move it (possibly push it by placing your hands on the prop). You want to be sure that if you accidentally move the prop it doesn't kick over. You want to make sure that a P-Lead didn't disconnect in flight, the run-up is for checking mag quality and plug fouling, the shutdown is for checking p-lead.
      – Ron Beyer
      Nov 20 at 16:36













    up vote
    22
    down vote



    accepted







    up vote
    22
    down vote



    accepted






    This is a hot-mag check to verify that when you shut the engine down, you are really putting it in a safe(r) state. Think about how the mag-switch works, when you switch to R or L, it grounds the P-Lead on the other side (so switching to R grounds the P-Lead on the Left side). If you don't see the RPM drop, you may have a hot mag on that side.



    An un-grounded mag is a dangerous situation in that it can cause the aircraft engine to turn over if you accidentally (or intentionally) move the prop when you are parking the aircraft, or when somebody walks by and runs into your prop.



    So during this mag check you are only looking for an RPM drop or a change that tells you that the mag is shut off.






    share|improve this answer












    This is a hot-mag check to verify that when you shut the engine down, you are really putting it in a safe(r) state. Think about how the mag-switch works, when you switch to R or L, it grounds the P-Lead on the other side (so switching to R grounds the P-Lead on the Left side). If you don't see the RPM drop, you may have a hot mag on that side.



    An un-grounded mag is a dangerous situation in that it can cause the aircraft engine to turn over if you accidentally (or intentionally) move the prop when you are parking the aircraft, or when somebody walks by and runs into your prop.



    So during this mag check you are only looking for an RPM drop or a change that tells you that the mag is shut off.







    share|improve this answer












    share|improve this answer



    share|improve this answer










    answered Nov 20 at 13:36









    Ron Beyer

    20.4k27298




    20.4k27298








    • 1




      That’s what I was taught, but really, isn’t testing each mag for a drop doing the same thing? It won’t drop if there’s a ground. I guess that wouldn’t verify no ground in the switch itself when set to OFF.
      – Greg Taylor
      Nov 20 at 16:29






    • 4




      Yes, the reason you do it at shutdown though is that you've just finished flying the aircraft and you are about to move it (possibly push it by placing your hands on the prop). You want to be sure that if you accidentally move the prop it doesn't kick over. You want to make sure that a P-Lead didn't disconnect in flight, the run-up is for checking mag quality and plug fouling, the shutdown is for checking p-lead.
      – Ron Beyer
      Nov 20 at 16:36














    • 1




      That’s what I was taught, but really, isn’t testing each mag for a drop doing the same thing? It won’t drop if there’s a ground. I guess that wouldn’t verify no ground in the switch itself when set to OFF.
      – Greg Taylor
      Nov 20 at 16:29






    • 4




      Yes, the reason you do it at shutdown though is that you've just finished flying the aircraft and you are about to move it (possibly push it by placing your hands on the prop). You want to be sure that if you accidentally move the prop it doesn't kick over. You want to make sure that a P-Lead didn't disconnect in flight, the run-up is for checking mag quality and plug fouling, the shutdown is for checking p-lead.
      – Ron Beyer
      Nov 20 at 16:36








    1




    1




    That’s what I was taught, but really, isn’t testing each mag for a drop doing the same thing? It won’t drop if there’s a ground. I guess that wouldn’t verify no ground in the switch itself when set to OFF.
    – Greg Taylor
    Nov 20 at 16:29




    That’s what I was taught, but really, isn’t testing each mag for a drop doing the same thing? It won’t drop if there’s a ground. I guess that wouldn’t verify no ground in the switch itself when set to OFF.
    – Greg Taylor
    Nov 20 at 16:29




    4




    4




    Yes, the reason you do it at shutdown though is that you've just finished flying the aircraft and you are about to move it (possibly push it by placing your hands on the prop). You want to be sure that if you accidentally move the prop it doesn't kick over. You want to make sure that a P-Lead didn't disconnect in flight, the run-up is for checking mag quality and plug fouling, the shutdown is for checking p-lead.
    – Ron Beyer
    Nov 20 at 16:36




    Yes, the reason you do it at shutdown though is that you've just finished flying the aircraft and you are about to move it (possibly push it by placing your hands on the prop). You want to be sure that if you accidentally move the prop it doesn't kick over. You want to make sure that a P-Lead didn't disconnect in flight, the run-up is for checking mag quality and plug fouling, the shutdown is for checking p-lead.
    – Ron Beyer
    Nov 20 at 16:36










    up vote
    10
    down vote













    You are doing it wrong if you are just cycling left/right/both. It is a hot mag check, not a mag function check like on a runup. You are supposed to cycle them to OFF and then back on to BOTH before shutdown and listen for the sound of combustion stopping in the exhaust. You do it after the engine has had time to cool down and while the engine is at idle to avoid backfires.



    Remember that magnetos are disabled (shut off) by grounding out the primary circuit. If the P lead, the ground out wire, to the ignition switch breaks, the mag is prevented from turning off and remains live. You are making sure they are grounding out and really shutting off so you don't have an undetetected live mag after shutdown. You have to do this because shutdown is done with the mixture cutoff and if the one mag is live after being turned off you won't know it, and a surprise could occur if the prop is moved later and the mag fires with residual fuel mixture in the cylinders.






    share|improve this answer

















    • 2




      I don't think you adequately explain why it is wrong to cycle left/right/both. My understanding is that if there's a mag drop on left, and another one on right then it proves both mags are grounding properly as well as turning the key to off. Turning it to off means you get fuel in the exhaust system.
      – GdD
      Nov 20 at 16:28










    • To get a noticeable mag drop you have to have some power on. This check is done just before shutting down, when at idle. Yes a bit of unburned fuel gets through, but when done at idle after the engine's cooled down it's not sufficient to cause a back fire and when you put the mags back on you're back to normal. You only have them switched off for a quarter to half a second. I've been doing it for 40+ years and have never had a backfire.
      – John K
      Nov 20 at 17:54















    up vote
    10
    down vote













    You are doing it wrong if you are just cycling left/right/both. It is a hot mag check, not a mag function check like on a runup. You are supposed to cycle them to OFF and then back on to BOTH before shutdown and listen for the sound of combustion stopping in the exhaust. You do it after the engine has had time to cool down and while the engine is at idle to avoid backfires.



    Remember that magnetos are disabled (shut off) by grounding out the primary circuit. If the P lead, the ground out wire, to the ignition switch breaks, the mag is prevented from turning off and remains live. You are making sure they are grounding out and really shutting off so you don't have an undetetected live mag after shutdown. You have to do this because shutdown is done with the mixture cutoff and if the one mag is live after being turned off you won't know it, and a surprise could occur if the prop is moved later and the mag fires with residual fuel mixture in the cylinders.






    share|improve this answer

















    • 2




      I don't think you adequately explain why it is wrong to cycle left/right/both. My understanding is that if there's a mag drop on left, and another one on right then it proves both mags are grounding properly as well as turning the key to off. Turning it to off means you get fuel in the exhaust system.
      – GdD
      Nov 20 at 16:28










    • To get a noticeable mag drop you have to have some power on. This check is done just before shutting down, when at idle. Yes a bit of unburned fuel gets through, but when done at idle after the engine's cooled down it's not sufficient to cause a back fire and when you put the mags back on you're back to normal. You only have them switched off for a quarter to half a second. I've been doing it for 40+ years and have never had a backfire.
      – John K
      Nov 20 at 17:54













    up vote
    10
    down vote










    up vote
    10
    down vote









    You are doing it wrong if you are just cycling left/right/both. It is a hot mag check, not a mag function check like on a runup. You are supposed to cycle them to OFF and then back on to BOTH before shutdown and listen for the sound of combustion stopping in the exhaust. You do it after the engine has had time to cool down and while the engine is at idle to avoid backfires.



    Remember that magnetos are disabled (shut off) by grounding out the primary circuit. If the P lead, the ground out wire, to the ignition switch breaks, the mag is prevented from turning off and remains live. You are making sure they are grounding out and really shutting off so you don't have an undetetected live mag after shutdown. You have to do this because shutdown is done with the mixture cutoff and if the one mag is live after being turned off you won't know it, and a surprise could occur if the prop is moved later and the mag fires with residual fuel mixture in the cylinders.






    share|improve this answer












    You are doing it wrong if you are just cycling left/right/both. It is a hot mag check, not a mag function check like on a runup. You are supposed to cycle them to OFF and then back on to BOTH before shutdown and listen for the sound of combustion stopping in the exhaust. You do it after the engine has had time to cool down and while the engine is at idle to avoid backfires.



    Remember that magnetos are disabled (shut off) by grounding out the primary circuit. If the P lead, the ground out wire, to the ignition switch breaks, the mag is prevented from turning off and remains live. You are making sure they are grounding out and really shutting off so you don't have an undetetected live mag after shutdown. You have to do this because shutdown is done with the mixture cutoff and if the one mag is live after being turned off you won't know it, and a surprise could occur if the prop is moved later and the mag fires with residual fuel mixture in the cylinders.







    share|improve this answer












    share|improve this answer



    share|improve this answer










    answered Nov 20 at 13:33









    John K

    11.9k11138




    11.9k11138








    • 2




      I don't think you adequately explain why it is wrong to cycle left/right/both. My understanding is that if there's a mag drop on left, and another one on right then it proves both mags are grounding properly as well as turning the key to off. Turning it to off means you get fuel in the exhaust system.
      – GdD
      Nov 20 at 16:28










    • To get a noticeable mag drop you have to have some power on. This check is done just before shutting down, when at idle. Yes a bit of unburned fuel gets through, but when done at idle after the engine's cooled down it's not sufficient to cause a back fire and when you put the mags back on you're back to normal. You only have them switched off for a quarter to half a second. I've been doing it for 40+ years and have never had a backfire.
      – John K
      Nov 20 at 17:54














    • 2




      I don't think you adequately explain why it is wrong to cycle left/right/both. My understanding is that if there's a mag drop on left, and another one on right then it proves both mags are grounding properly as well as turning the key to off. Turning it to off means you get fuel in the exhaust system.
      – GdD
      Nov 20 at 16:28










    • To get a noticeable mag drop you have to have some power on. This check is done just before shutting down, when at idle. Yes a bit of unburned fuel gets through, but when done at idle after the engine's cooled down it's not sufficient to cause a back fire and when you put the mags back on you're back to normal. You only have them switched off for a quarter to half a second. I've been doing it for 40+ years and have never had a backfire.
      – John K
      Nov 20 at 17:54








    2




    2




    I don't think you adequately explain why it is wrong to cycle left/right/both. My understanding is that if there's a mag drop on left, and another one on right then it proves both mags are grounding properly as well as turning the key to off. Turning it to off means you get fuel in the exhaust system.
    – GdD
    Nov 20 at 16:28




    I don't think you adequately explain why it is wrong to cycle left/right/both. My understanding is that if there's a mag drop on left, and another one on right then it proves both mags are grounding properly as well as turning the key to off. Turning it to off means you get fuel in the exhaust system.
    – GdD
    Nov 20 at 16:28












    To get a noticeable mag drop you have to have some power on. This check is done just before shutting down, when at idle. Yes a bit of unburned fuel gets through, but when done at idle after the engine's cooled down it's not sufficient to cause a back fire and when you put the mags back on you're back to normal. You only have them switched off for a quarter to half a second. I've been doing it for 40+ years and have never had a backfire.
    – John K
    Nov 20 at 17:54




    To get a noticeable mag drop you have to have some power on. This check is done just before shutting down, when at idle. Yes a bit of unburned fuel gets through, but when done at idle after the engine's cooled down it's not sufficient to cause a back fire and when you put the mags back on you're back to normal. You only have them switched off for a quarter to half a second. I've been doing it for 40+ years and have never had a backfire.
    – John K
    Nov 20 at 17:54










    up vote
    4
    down vote













    This is going to give the same reason as Ron Beyer's answer. I'm only writing another because I found his a little hard to follow and I'm going to try to explain it differently. It's nothing to do with mag fouling at all.





    The magnetos are wired up so that a failure of the switch or wiring leaves them live (on), unlike most electrical devices which are wired to be off if they fail. This is normally what you want because if the wiring fails in-flight, you'd like the magnetos to keep working. But it can cause a dangerous state, where the magnetos are stuck on when you think they're off. If you swung the prop in that condition, it could fire when you're not expecting it.



    So one at a time, we switch a magneto off, and check that the RPM appears to drop, and that the engine sound changes. The sound is more important - as John K says, the drop is small at the kind of RPM you do your mag drop test, and hard to see unambiguously on the gauge. This way, you know that switching it off really does isolate the magneto, so you know that when you turn both off after stopping the engine, the propeller is safe.



    It's not so much for your benefit as whoever will touch or fly the aircraft next. Even so, you should always treat a propeller as live. If you have to swing it (e.g. to inspect it), do so as if you were hand-cranking the engine, keeping well clear and making sure your arm comes out of its path.






    share|improve this answer

























      up vote
      4
      down vote













      This is going to give the same reason as Ron Beyer's answer. I'm only writing another because I found his a little hard to follow and I'm going to try to explain it differently. It's nothing to do with mag fouling at all.





      The magnetos are wired up so that a failure of the switch or wiring leaves them live (on), unlike most electrical devices which are wired to be off if they fail. This is normally what you want because if the wiring fails in-flight, you'd like the magnetos to keep working. But it can cause a dangerous state, where the magnetos are stuck on when you think they're off. If you swung the prop in that condition, it could fire when you're not expecting it.



      So one at a time, we switch a magneto off, and check that the RPM appears to drop, and that the engine sound changes. The sound is more important - as John K says, the drop is small at the kind of RPM you do your mag drop test, and hard to see unambiguously on the gauge. This way, you know that switching it off really does isolate the magneto, so you know that when you turn both off after stopping the engine, the propeller is safe.



      It's not so much for your benefit as whoever will touch or fly the aircraft next. Even so, you should always treat a propeller as live. If you have to swing it (e.g. to inspect it), do so as if you were hand-cranking the engine, keeping well clear and making sure your arm comes out of its path.






      share|improve this answer























        up vote
        4
        down vote










        up vote
        4
        down vote









        This is going to give the same reason as Ron Beyer's answer. I'm only writing another because I found his a little hard to follow and I'm going to try to explain it differently. It's nothing to do with mag fouling at all.





        The magnetos are wired up so that a failure of the switch or wiring leaves them live (on), unlike most electrical devices which are wired to be off if they fail. This is normally what you want because if the wiring fails in-flight, you'd like the magnetos to keep working. But it can cause a dangerous state, where the magnetos are stuck on when you think they're off. If you swung the prop in that condition, it could fire when you're not expecting it.



        So one at a time, we switch a magneto off, and check that the RPM appears to drop, and that the engine sound changes. The sound is more important - as John K says, the drop is small at the kind of RPM you do your mag drop test, and hard to see unambiguously on the gauge. This way, you know that switching it off really does isolate the magneto, so you know that when you turn both off after stopping the engine, the propeller is safe.



        It's not so much for your benefit as whoever will touch or fly the aircraft next. Even so, you should always treat a propeller as live. If you have to swing it (e.g. to inspect it), do so as if you were hand-cranking the engine, keeping well clear and making sure your arm comes out of its path.






        share|improve this answer












        This is going to give the same reason as Ron Beyer's answer. I'm only writing another because I found his a little hard to follow and I'm going to try to explain it differently. It's nothing to do with mag fouling at all.





        The magnetos are wired up so that a failure of the switch or wiring leaves them live (on), unlike most electrical devices which are wired to be off if they fail. This is normally what you want because if the wiring fails in-flight, you'd like the magnetos to keep working. But it can cause a dangerous state, where the magnetos are stuck on when you think they're off. If you swung the prop in that condition, it could fire when you're not expecting it.



        So one at a time, we switch a magneto off, and check that the RPM appears to drop, and that the engine sound changes. The sound is more important - as John K says, the drop is small at the kind of RPM you do your mag drop test, and hard to see unambiguously on the gauge. This way, you know that switching it off really does isolate the magneto, so you know that when you turn both off after stopping the engine, the propeller is safe.



        It's not so much for your benefit as whoever will touch or fly the aircraft next. Even so, you should always treat a propeller as live. If you have to swing it (e.g. to inspect it), do so as if you were hand-cranking the engine, keeping well clear and making sure your arm comes out of its path.







        share|improve this answer












        share|improve this answer



        share|improve this answer










        answered Nov 21 at 9:04









        Dan Hulme

        9,33714174




        9,33714174






























            draft saved

            draft discarded




















































            Thanks for contributing an answer to Aviation Stack Exchange!


            • Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!

            But avoid



            • Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.

            • Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.


            Use MathJax to format equations. MathJax reference.


            To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.





            Some of your past answers have not been well-received, and you're in danger of being blocked from answering.


            Please pay close attention to the following guidance:


            • Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!

            But avoid



            • Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.

            • Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.


            To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.




            draft saved


            draft discarded














            StackExchange.ready(
            function () {
            StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2faviation.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f57290%2fwhy-cycle-the-magnetos-before-engine-shutdown%23new-answer', 'question_page');
            }
            );

            Post as a guest















            Required, but never shown





















































            Required, but never shown














            Required, but never shown












            Required, but never shown







            Required, but never shown

































            Required, but never shown














            Required, but never shown












            Required, but never shown







            Required, but never shown







            Popular posts from this blog

            Plaza Victoria

            In PowerPoint, is there a keyboard shortcut for bulleted / numbered list?

            How to put 3 figures in Latex with 2 figures side by side and 1 below these side by side images but in...